User:KellyAnnDrew/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Maria Mitchell

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it is the topic of our group project, and I want to evaluate it critically to think about what areas we might be able to improve. It is ranked as an important article because she is an important historical figure.

Evaluate the article
Lead: good, but needs a little more information to reflect each of the sections.

Content: middle and late years can be expanded, the early years has more information in comparison. death and honors section maybe should be split into two different sections.

Tone: does not seem totally neutral, I can tell the author is passionate about the subject. Might need some editing.

Sources: can definitely add in some sources throughout.

Organization and writing quality: excellent

Images: one of the images needs a more detailed caption.

Talk page: C-class, much of the edits have been adding sources and asking to expand certain sections or add sections.

Overall: can add more details to certain sections and add more sources, maybe even add more sections or switch the divisions between certain sections (add 'personal life', divide 'death and honors', expand 'middle years' and 'late years' and 'social issues')