User:Kgroft/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
The Book of Eli

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose it because I am looking for perspective articles to work on for my wiki project. My first impression is that it was very thorough, yet concise. The content was great and I saw immediately that they had an extensive list of references which only supported my initial take that it was a great article.

Evaluate the article
Lead Section

The lead section was strong, yet concise. It did a great job of setting the tone for the rest of the article, succinctly allowing for the reader to understand exactly what the subject matter was.

Content

The content of the article was extremely well formulated. Though it was dense, it covered all of what had happened in the film in terms of plot.

Tone and Balance

It was a well balanced piece, moving from point to point very well. There was no bias throughout--only facts. It was very matter of fact, as I understand this articles are supposed to be.

Sources and References

There were 28 reference and 6 external links. I think this section was extremely diligent.

Organization and Writing Quality

Both organization and writing quality were very good. As I said before, good flow throughout the whole article.

Images and Media

This might be the only thing lacking in this article. There is only one photo in the whole piece.

Talk Page and Discussions

On the talk page, there are few things still in the process of being changed, but they are very minor things like adding a producer, or specifying what "it" means when referring to the book in the beginning of the article.

Overall Impressions

I thought it was a very thorough article that has gone above and beyond in terms of the references, which only strengthens my trust that it very good article.