User:Kilo2003/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Adoration of the Magi (Gentile da Fabriano)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because the altarpiece is full of detail and cultural transfusion and there is a lot of great topics and information that can be learned and studied from this work. Also, there isn't much information on it so my group and I are excited to fill it with more information for people to learn more about this piece. Also, I am a Christian/Catholic, so the Adoration of the Magi is a bible story that resonates with my culture.

Evaluate the article
I believe the lead section can be improved because it doesn't not give enough summarized explanation of what the Adoration of the Magi really is. In terms of topic, the article is lacking a lot of information because there is so many topics and ideas to delve into and explore from the altarpiece that the article does not have yet. The article is relevant to the topic, but just lacks a lot of information. There is only one source cited in the article so far, and it is pretty contemporary since its from 2001, but it lacks more sources. The article has many pictures already which add value to it, and they are referenced as well. Overall, the article is lacking content, so it can be improved by explaining more topics about the altarpiece such as the materials, the symbolism, the cultural transfusion incorporated in the painting, and much more. The tone of the article is neutral and there does not seem to be any claims that are very biased. The links seem to work, but lack enough sources since there is only one. The article was rated as a Stub-Class for quality scale.