User:KnowledgeSeeker2024/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Seas

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I'm a big Jules Verne fan and this book in particular has a special place in my heart.

Evaluate the article
Everything in the article was related to the topic of said article. It provided interesting insight into parallels between Twenty-Thousand Leagues and other pieces of literature, such as Homer's Odyssey as well, and I actually learned new information. While the article provided information about the English translations, I noticed that it didn't provide information about any other translations. I believe that the article could benefit from their inclusions. I also felt that more insight could have been added into the public perception section.

The article, for all intents and purposes, does seem to be neutral, and no viewpoints are underrepresented. The links to the citations I tried did work. Most of the sources provided did tend to be Western, but the book was catered largely to a Western audience and so I won't be too harsh on that.

The article's talk page addresses typos, how to speak about certain things, and contradictions withing the article among other things, including things that certain people wanted removed and also non-English translations, which I mentioned earlier!