User:Kwang1484/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Mary Hamilton Swindler

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Mary Hamilton Swindler is a renowned scholar of classical art and archaeologist, and I'm very interested in archaeology which is a very important part of the study of history. She was also the first female editor of the American Journal of Archaeology, and I think her life story is wonderfully worthy of being studied.

Evaluate the article
Evaluate the content

All of the content in the article is relevant to the topic and describes the life story of Mary Hamilton Swindler. There are some elements that are repeatedly mentioned, which I think can be removed after summarizing.

Evaluate the Tone

The tone is neutral and perfect for Wikipedia.

Evaluate sources

Every link is working, and a large amount of content comes from the same sources. Many of these sources come from universities and museums and are, in my opinion, very authoritative academic sources.

Check the talk page

Someone on the talk page pointed out that the article had had inconsistent birth dates.

The article was rated C. It was included in the Women Scientists and Women Historians topic but was not of high importance. It has moderate importance in the Pennsylvania and Indiana related content.