User:Lar/sandbox2

William M. Connolley comment editing restriction modification
Attention: This request may be declined without further action if insufficient or unclear information is provided in the "Request" section below.

Request concerning William M. Connolley comment editing restriction modification

 * User requesting modification : ++Lar: t/c 17:56, 21 August 2010 (UTC) (pro forma)


 * User whose modification of restriction is proposed :


 * Sanction or remedy that has been modified
 * Original text:
 * is prohibited from editing comments made by other editors, for a duration of two months.
 * Modification (modified section bolded) which was done in these edits:
 * is prohibited from editing comments made by other editors about climate change or that appear on discussion pages related to climate change (broadly interpreted), for a duration of two months.


 * Enforcement action requested (block, topic ban or other sanction) : Approve this revision of the original restriction, by arriving at consensus here that we should do so, or find that no consensus exists and restore the sanction to its original form.


 * Additional comments by editor filing complaint : There is a lot of backstory, hopefully most folk are aware of it and it doesn't need repeating, but after a series of blocks, extensions, shortenings and an unblock, (with much AN/I discussion) unilaterally modified the sanction text, claiming consensus existed at ANI. It is not clear to me that such consensus existed, so I've reverted the change to the status quo ante.


 * Notification of the user against whom enforcement is requested : Not applicable but I will place a link in the ANI discussion to this page shortly.

Result concerning William M. Connolley comment editing restriction modification

 * This section is to be edited only by uninvolved administrators and is not to be used by others to conduct discusson or debate. Comments by non-admins, and any discussion or debate by other than uninvolved administrators, will be moved to the section above. Adminstrators engaged in extended discussion or debate, especially if not directly related to the proposed outcome, should strongly consider using the above sections.
 * There is disagreement as to the acceptability of any threaded discussions in this section. Please see Template_talk:Climate_Sanction_enforcement_request before engaging in any threaded discussions.