User:Leekatie212/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
The article that I am evaluating is the following: 475: Break the Silence.

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I have decided to evaluate this article because 475: Break the Silence was categorized as a Stub-Class article, indicating that there is very little development to corroborate and to explain the topic. Moreover, at just first glance, it is clear that sections have not been completed, and it is difficult to learn more about the topic in depth despite reading the entirety of the article.

Evaluate the article
The lead section of the article 475: Break the Silence is fairly concise and straightforward—it is easy to follow along and understand that the title of the article is referring to a film set in Morocco. However, it fails to describe any major sections that will be discussed, and includes information that is not further elaborated in the article.

In regards to content, all of the sections that have been created by the author are incomplete. For instance, with "Plot" and "Cast," both sections are completely empty and have been flagged by Wikipedia since October 2020. Moreover, the article cites seven sources that are mostly sites where viewers could watch the film and reviews from film critics. Therefore, this lack of content makes it difficult to determine whether the author is biased and whether the language's tone is affirmative of critical towards the film. The talk page is quite barren, as there is no conversation going on at all, and the article is under WikiProject Film and rated as a stub-class article with low-importance as per its quality and completeness.

Overall, it would be better if the article could be developed and completed before one could re-evaluate the merit of it. For one, as it is a film, it would be helpful to add a brief summary of the plot and include a list of the cast. It is essential that the article is divided into major sections, and that sufficient research and contribution is done to each part. Additionally, adding an image of the poster of the movie or some quotes or scenes from the movie would help visualize what the film is about. While not urgent, it would be great to have section that touches on the significance of the film or a part that explains why the film was highly praised by critics and film festivals.