User:LeonorAlcaraz/sandbox/Article Evaluations

Christopher Heath Wellman

-In Wellman's book Debating the Ethics of Immigration: Is There a Right to Exclude? he argues that all legitimate states have the right to closed borders because states have freedom of association, therefore they have the freedom to exclude or admit people. This is only true if the state is legitimate, which means that it respects the basic human rights of all of its members. While he argues that states have the right to exclude, he doesn't say they should, instead he focuses on explaining how/why states have this right.

Joseph Carens Summarize Carens views on immigration in a more straightforward way