User:Lil Scar II/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title: Philip Vera Cruz:
 * Article Evaluation: Cruz’s article out of the 3 articles has the most information. The content I’d say is relevant to my topic due to Cruz’s significance towards the Delano grape strike because Cruz is another major figure of the strike with Filipino descent. Content written has no biased opinions thus approving Wikipedia’s neutrality rule. Each claim and section has a citation. This article has the most citations from various outside articles however no citation of an article used from recent years. Since the Filipino American aspect of the strike is lessor known, I’d say it is underrepresented. Talk page looks inactive and looks to be inactive for a long time. :
 * Sources: Decent number of sources for Cruz's article since he seems to not be well known for his role in the Delano Grape Strike. No websites external links that aren't articles :

Option 2

 * Article title: Community Service Organization:
 * Article Evaluation: I’d say the content is partially relevant towards my topic. Although the amount of content in the article is only a small amount and could use major improvements if more sources are found, especially on Filipinos. Neutrality opinion is present although slightly lens towards Latino Americans. All paragraphs have at least one citation, however since the amount of content is very little, the only citations that the few paragraphs have stand on the few citations they have. Citations seem questionable since its only a few which may hinder the article’s reliability. This article looks quite underrepresented due to the low amount of content and underrepresentation of Filipinos. Talk page looks inactive and no present activity in the talk page as well. :
 * Sources: Only 5 sources in total but still be improved with more sources although finding them would be quite a task. 3 external website links that aren't citated articles. :

Option 3

 * Article title: Mutualista:
 * Article Evaluation: This article I also say that its also partially relevant to my topic. Although just like my second article, there’s a small amount of content and could use major improvements as well. Similarly, to my second article, there’s a lean towards Latino Americans since the organization was founded for Latino immigrants. Some paragraphs’ claims don’t have a citation. The citations themselves seem questionable since there’s almost practically none which I saw significantly affects the article’s reliability. The overall content seems underrepresented due to the low amount of content and no representation on Filipinos. Inactive talk page with the lowest amount of editor contribution. :
 * Sources: Fewer than 5 articles which also signifies that the article needs improvement regarding its usage of sources. No websites external links that aren't articles. :

Option 4

 * Article title:
 * Article Evaluation:
 * Sources:

Option 5

 * Article title:
 * Article Evaluation:
 * Sources: