User:Lilylucero13/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?

Luna (tree)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?

I chose to evaluate this article because it has historical implications relating to topics I am interested in such as environmentalism, activism, and degradation caused by resource-depleting corporations. These histories are important as they form part of the larger landscape of environmentalism. I was initially interested in Luna because of the way in which it was defended and how I thought I understood it related to other tree-saving projects I have learned about.

Evaluate the article:

The article about Luna is fairly short yet very interesting, especially the negotiations between Julia Butterfly Hill and Pacific Lumber Company. The article does address that there has been some misinformation regarding Luna's location and I am curious about any further misinformation. I would also like to see in the article how this relates to other demonstrations of environmental activism. It appears to be mostly unbiased and rooted in fact. There are many resources from a variety of authors and external links. It is part of the WikiProject Plants and the talk page includes some comments on inconsistencies found regarding Luna's vandalism.