User:Listeningstars/Evaluate an Article

Suger's Eagle
(Provide a link to the article here.)

== I thought it was the most different and interesting looking item on the list. It also didnt appear to be a flat object, but one that is three dimensional and I took interest in the details. This object is a vase from ancient egypt so it holds some potential for attatchments to egyptian wealth, and it appears to be made of gold and perhaps some sort of marble, which made it stand out to me as being something of value and importance. ==

(Briefly explain why you chose it, why it matters, and what your preliminary impression of it was.)

== The lead of this article describes the object plainly, explaining what it is and where it comes from. It includes a brief description of what the vase is made of as well but it is very short. There is very little content on this item, but it does all appear to be relevant to the vase and its context, most of the article describing the embeleshments of the vase and what it is made of/looks like. The article was last updated in December of 2023, which was very recently all things considered. The article is overall very neutral In tone and really only states facts about the appearance of the vase. Most of the links do not work or are broken so it is a bit hard to check if the sources are reliable or not, which could prove to be problematic. The few that did link properly semed to be from books. The article is easy to read, but does not provide much to think about due to how short it is. It lacks any detailed context as to what the vase actually is or represents. There is one image in this article and it is easy to see the vase, however, I do think more images with different angles of the vase would be helpful and nice for viewers. There is currently nothing on the talk page for this article. My overall impression here is that, while the article provides some basic information on the vase, it could do more. There is good base structure for potential, but more images and details about the vase should be added. I would say the article is ultimately underdevloped and could use more work. ==

(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)