User:M1dn1ght F0r3st/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Liminal space (aesthetic)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I have an intense interest in liminal spaces. This article is important because it gives basic information without overwhelming the reader. My preliminary impression of this article was that is was well written and provides the most basic information to the reader without needing the reader to research other things first.

Evaluate the article
The lead to this article contains an introductory sentence that is concise and clearly conveys the article’s topic. It includes a brief description about the major sections in the article. No information was added that wasn’t present in the main portion of the article and the lead is concise and not overly detailed. The content in the article is relevant to the topic of liminal spaces along with the content being up to date. There is no content missing or extra content that does not belong. This article does not seem to deal with one of Wikipedia’s equity gaps. The article is very neutral and does not claim to appear heavily biased in any position. No viewpoints are overly presented or underrepresented. The article does not try to persuade the reader in any way. The sources for this article thorough, current, and include a diverse spectrum of authors. I don’t believe there could be better sources as this article covers more than what the average person would be able to cite even if they have researched this their entire lives. Links in this article do work. The article is well-written with little to no visible grammatical or spelling errors. It is also well-organized and is broken down into proper sections that definitely reflect the major points of the topic. The images in this article are well captioned, they adhere to the copyright regulations, and are very appealing. I don’t know if this article is apart of WikiProjects. The articles overall status is really good. It excels in its explanation of how liminal spaces came to be. It could improve more by talking about the current internet culture about it. I’d give this article a 4.5 out of 5.