User:MHD2021/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
List of tallest buildings in New Orleans

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it directly pertains to the course I am taking, as it focuses on the tallest buildings in New Orleans. This article matters because it gives more insight on the architecture within the city. My first impression of the article is that is looks complete and very organized, with links to and a small description of each building on the list.

Evaluate the article
Overall, the information in the article seemed complete. There was no aspect that was distracting or took away from the entire article. Some of the buildings did not have a picture associated with them, and there were a few citations that were missing. Most of the buildings included in the list did not have a description despite having a section for that. The article can be improved by including a description for each building. The article is neutral when presenting the information and objectively presents facts about the heights of the buildings.

The citations that I checked work, but they do not seem to be the most reliable sources. The majority of the citations included come from the same two sources, SkyscraperPage and Emporis. These sources present information about skyscraper data. Other sources included are newspaper sources, though they mainly appear to have a neutral standpoint when presenting information.

There are conversations asking for clarity on one subject, sections listing buildings that were excluded from the original page, and some people stating the changes they have made to the external links. The article is rated is FL class- low/mid importance and is located in various WikiProjects regarding its architecture and location in New Orleans. This article takes on a standpoint that is a lot more neutral than some of the readings in the class.