User:Maameer

Synopsis
The Prophet’s birth was recorded according to the then existing calendar as 12th Rabiul Awwal Monday in the Elephant year. The calculated date according to AD is 20-4-571AD. This date does not correspond to 12-3-53BH. The author inspects this and gives a method for calculating the correct date of the Prophet’s birth. Those interested may try it and know the truth.

The exact date of the Prophet's birth
(Peace be upon him) The exact date of the Prophet Muhammad's (pbuh) birth has not been determined so far and we do not know the correct date of his birth according to the Christian calendar. Historians and astronomers who had worked on this subject in the past have given various dates for the Prophetâ€™s birth. Even the famous Encyclopedia Britannica gives doubtful dates and puts a question mark as to the year of his birth. From this it is clearly known that the world is not sure of the date on which the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), who claimed to be the last of the prophets, was born.

The commonly accepted date for the Prophetâ€™s birth is 20th April 571 AD. It is said that the famous astronomer Mahmood Pasha of Egypt, who lived in the 19th century, calculated this date. Calculations reveal that this date does not tally with the date recorded according to the Arabic calendar, which was same as the Hebrew calendar. The date of the Prophet's birth according to that calendar is 12th of Rabiul Awwal of the Elephant Era.

The historic records say that the Christians had build a church in order to attract the Arabs, but the Kaâ€™aba attracted more attention than the newly built place of worship and Abraha, the Governor of Yemen, came to Mecca to destroy the Kaâ€™aba, the long revered place of worship of the Arabs. He brought an elephant to facilitate the task. But his plans were foiled and all ended in a disaster. The Holy Qurâ€™an refers to this event in the chapter 105. It is recorded that the Prophet was born after 55 days of the event, which occurred on the 17th of Muharram in the year 570 AD.

The examination of the scientific records of the phases of the moon for the year 570 AD reveals that this date is Monday the 5th of May 570 AD. The moon was eclipsed on Tuesday the 6th of May 570 just before the infant Muhammad (pbuh) completed the first day of his life on the Earth

According to the songs remembered since time immemorial, it is Monday, the 12th of Rabiul Awwal. At that time their calendar had a fixed number of days for the twelve months; Muharram, Safar, Rabiul Awwal, Rabiul akhar, Jamadul awwal, Jamadul akhar, Rajab, Shahaban, Ramadan, Shawwal, Zul kaâ€™ad, and Zul hajj.

The twelve months of the year had 30 or 29 days alternating from Muharram to Zulhajj with an occasional leap year in which Zulhajj got 30 days, in order to adjust with the natural system. In this artificial lunar calendar, which was same as the Hebrew Calendar, the dates need not necessarily tally with the phases of the Moon. The full moon occurred on the 12th or13th and the new moon on the 28th or 29th in the Arabic calendar as against the 14th or 15th for the full moon and the 29th or 30th for the new moon in the Islamic calendar in which the dates must tally with the phases of the Moon.

The Arabic calendar is better than many others of its kind, because the error accumulated in 2000 years in it is only one day. The Jews use this calendar even today.

Islam does not accept even this minute error in recording time. A mistake in recording historic events can create a lot of confusion to the posterity. The error in calculating the date of the Prophetâ€™s birth is only due to this confusion. It had baffled even the renowned astronomers and their calculations have gone wrong. People are made to believe a falsehood about the Prophet! How can Islam, which is the perfect code of life for mankind, tolerate such a serious mistake? So Islam has prescribed an error-free dating system for the people. The last Prophet in his last days during the Hajjathul Wida gave instructions to reform their calendar.

During the Hajjathul Wida he laid down rules and regulations for the Islamic Calendar. He made the seven days of the week and the dates, which represented them, and the months, which depended on the lunar cycle, sacred and inviolable. He named the months in which war is forbidden (Ash-hurul hurum) as Zul Qaid, Zul hajj, Muharram and Rajab. The Qurâ€™an explains this automatic cease-fire arrangement in the verse 9:36. All wars must cease in these months, which allows a warring people enough time to think of the after effects of a war. The Prophet abolished the use of a leap year and ordered them to use the dates of the natural calendar, which depended strictly on the Manzils (the phases) of the Moon. He wanted the calendar to be fully natural so that there will not be any adjustments and confusion in future. All other calendars need periodical adjustments known as intercalation (Nasie) which is forbidden in the Qur'an.(9:37)

The Gregorian calendar, now in vogue in the world for recording the dates of events in history is not scientific. It accumulates errors in course of time and the accumulated days have to be removed at intervals. Whenever this is done, the method of calculation would change and the calendar must be renamed. The present calendar was known as the Julian calendar in the beginning. In 1582 AD the Pope Gregory 13 reformed it after removing 10 days, which had accumulated in that calendar by then. It was renamed as the Gregorian calendar.

The calculation methods in Julian and Gregorian periods are different. So if the date calculations are made without taking the intercalations into consideration, the results would be wrong and this is serious. Telling a lie about the Prophet who forbade falsehood is not a simple thing in the sight of Allah (swt). If we tell his date of birth, we must tell the truth. Otherwise we should admit that we do not know. In a recent publication under the Board of Islamic Publications, the book entitled â€œThe Prophet Muhammad in the Indian context the Prophetâ€™s date of birth is given as on 20 or 22 April 571 AD. This clearly shows our ignorance about the dates. The fact that a person cannot be born on two dates is totally ignored.

The commonly accepted date for the Prophetâ€™s birth 20 or 22 April 571AD must correspond to 12th of Rabiul Awwal of the Arabic calendar. But according to the records, the year of the Elephant is 570, not 571AD. We can check whether this date is correct by simple calculations. The date of the Prophetâ€™s demise is recorded correctly, for he was famous when he passed away, on Monday the 8th of June 632 AD corresponding to the 12th of Rabiul Awwal in the Arabic calendar. The span of the Prophetâ€™s life can be calculated under two calendars. The number of days in both the calendars should be same if the dates are correct. It should be remembered that the 12th of the Arabic calendar corresponds to the 14th of the Islamic calendar.

Demise: 08 - 06 - 0632 AD = 12 - 03 - 0011 AH      Birth:     20 - 04 - 0571 AD = 12 - 03 - 0053 BH

* He passed away on Monday in the middle of Rabiul Awwal (full moon) * Hijra took place in Rabiul Awwal after 53 years of the Elephant Era. Now this has to be converted in to days to see whether both are equal. The number of days in the Christian and the Arabic year is 365.25(365.2422 true figure to be used for long periods) and 354.3671 days respectively.

Therefore: AH - 64 x 354.3671      = 22679.49 days AD - 61 x 365.25 + 50  = 22339.25 days Difference                  =     340.24 days

This difference of 340.24 days is because the dates in both the calendars are not correct. Therefore the mistake must be in the calculation of the Julian date for the Prophetâ€™s birth.

Now we can examine the Prophetâ€™s date of birth (05 - 05 - 0570 AD) which we have arrived at by following the ancient historic records.

Demise: 08 - 06 - 0632 AD      = 12 - 03 - 0011    AH                Birth    : 05 - 05 - 0570 AD       = 12 - 03 - 0053    BH                 03 - 01 - 0062 years     =  00 - 00 - 0064 years

Now let us convert this in to days so that both could be compared

62 x 365.25 + 31 +3 =  22679.500 days According to  Christian Era 64 x 354.3671         =  22679.494 days According to Muslim Era.

The absence of disparity proves that both the dates are correct. Now we can cross check this by using another method of calculation and see if we can get the same date. The Prophetâ€™s migration (Hijra) to Madeenah is an important event in the history. This is called the Hijra and Hijra Era began with this incident. The Prophet was 53 years old at that time. We can take the date of Miladunnabi of 1999 for this calculation. Date of Miladunnabi of 1999 = 27-06-1999AD = 14-03-1420AH Hijra Era attained 1420 lunar year on 27-06-1999. So the Prophetâ€™s age on this date would be 1420 + 53 = 1473 lunar years. This subtracted from the date 26-06-1999 should give the Prophetâ€™s date of birth according to Christian calendar. To enable this, 1473 lunar year must be converted in to Christian calendar.

Therefore: 1473 x 353.3671 / 365.2422 =1429.1413 years (1429 years 1 month and 21 days). That is: 0.1413 x 12 = 1.6956 months - To convert years to months multiply by 12.. 0.6956 x 30.43 = 21.167 Days -to convert months into days multiply by 30.43. Subtracting this 1429 - 01 - 21 from 1999 - 06 - 27 1999 - 06 - 27-         1429 - 01 - 21        =  0570 - 05 - 06AD Tuesday. But the Prophet was born on a Monday for certain. This discrepancy is due to the error in the Christian calendar. By deducting 1day to correct the error existing in the Christian calendar we get the true date as, 0570 - 05 - 05AD. Monday. These calculations prove beyond any doubt that the last Messenger of Allah, Muhammad (pbuh) was born on MONDAY the 05th of MAY 0570 AD according to the Christian Calendar.

ALI MANIKFAN 29/9/1420-5/1/2000