User:Maha Zubaidi/sandbox

Article Evaluation

Article: New Afrikan Black Panther Party


 * There was nothing distracting in the article.
 * The article did not seem biased, it read as neutral.
 * There are no viewpoints that seem overrepresented since the article only consisted of a brief history of the party.
 * The citation links all work, however they lead to official websites about the party leader. Therefore these sources do not seem to be independent or particularly reliable.
 * Since the article is extremely short, there is a lot that can be added.
 * After checking the talk page, it seems that the article was supposed to be deleted in 2012.
 * On the talk page, it is also discussed that the article is about a fringe organization, and that it may have been written by Rashid Johnson, the party leader, himself from jail.
 * The article is related because this party seems to be an offshoot of the original Black Panther party movement.
 * This article does not go into depth about the impact or significance of this party. Nor does it discuss different perspectives regarding the different perspectives people might have on the existence of this party from inside prison.