User:Maile66/PRcount

Peer reviews

 * Peer review

Reviews for others

 * Henry Hoʻolulu Pitman 2015.11.20
 * Peer review/Indian National Army 2015.10.21
 * American Civil War 2015.10.21

My reviews

 * Pershing House (pending 3 February 2022)
 * Texas Revolution 2015.02.11-17 (initiated by Karanacs)
 * Audie Murphy 2013.02.09

Content

 * Comprehensiveness:
 * The Basic Article adequately defines the subject and accurately provides the most basic and significant facts about it. It does not necessarily go into details or provide complex or extended description of any aspect of the topic.
 * The Good Article adequately defines the subject, and accurately describes all of the main aspects of the subject and provides the most significant details. It does not necessarily describe every aspect of the topic in depth.
 * The Excellent Article accurately defines the subject, accurately describes every relevant aspect of the subject, and assigns the due weight to each aspect of the topic without focusing unduly on specific aspects or neglecting others. Compliance with comprehensiveness requirements for EA articles may require soliciting and receiving an External Peer Review (see below).


 * Referencing:
 * The Basic Article complies with WP:V; it has inline citations to reliable sources for all information in the article. It includes no plagiarism or close paraphrasing.
 * The Good Article has inline citations to reliable sources including those for direct quotations, statistics, published opinion, counter-intuitive or controversial statements that are challenged or likely to be challenged, and contentious material relating to living persons; it has at least one inline citation in each paragraph. Citations are preferably to high quality sources. It shows an adequate engagement with the scholarly literature on the topic.
 * The Excellent Article includes inline citations to the best available sources and represents a thorough and representative survey of the relevant literature. Compliance with referencing requirements for EA articles may require soliciting and receiving an External Peer Review (see below).


 * Neutrality:
 * The Basic Article complies with WP:NPOV; it has no obvious bias or tendentious representation. It is not currently tagged for POV concerns or other forms of bias, and there are no on-going discussions about neutrality concerns or bias.
 * The Good Article comes across as objective and neutral, without obvious or implicit tendentious representation, the selection of sources and information is not tendentious or biased.
 * The Excellent Article is fully objective and neutral, and faithfully represents the state of knowledge in the fields of knowledge to which it pertains, it describes all notable and significant viewpoints according to the principle of due weight. Compliance with neutrality requirements for EA articles may require soliciting and receiving an External Peer Review (see below).

Style

 * Layout:
 * The Basic Article has an adequate definition sentence, and presents information in an accessible and organized manner.
 * The Good article is well-organized, it has an adequate lead and represents information in a structured manner with an adequate use of sections and subsections, it complies with the MOS layout requirements, and the requirements for lead sections, words to watch and embedded lists.
 * The Excellent Article is well-organized and complies fully with the MOS, has a well-written lead that is neither too long or too short and which serves as a full stand-alone summary of the article, and it has a graphically appealing lay-out without disturbing elements or layout glitches that detract from its visual presentation.


 * Citations:
 * The Basic Article includes sources for the information, and presents them in a way so that it is possible to identify the source of each piece of information.
 * The Good Article includes inline citations for all information and at least one citation in each paragraph, it contains a list of references which is presented in accordance with the layout style guideline
 * The Excellent Article includes inline citations for all information, consistently formatted in accordance with the MOS using either footnotes or Harvard referencing (Smith 2007, p. 1)—see citing sources for suggestions on formatting references. The use of citation templates is not required.


 * Length:
 * The Basic Article is at least one paragraph long, and contains more than 1,500 characters of prose.
 * The Good Article contains at least a Lead paragraph and a main section with any relevant subsections. It follows the Size Guideline.
 * The Excellent Article stays focused on the main topic without going into unnecessary detail and uses summary style.

Additional material

 * Media/Illustrations:
 * The Basic Article does not require media.
 * The Good Article is illustrated, if possible, by images which are tagged with their copyright status, and valid fair use rationales are provided for non-free content; and which are relevant to the topic, and have suitable captions.
 * The Excellent Article has images and other media, where appropriate, with succinct captions, and acceptable copyright status. Images included follow the image use policy. Non-free images or media must satisfy the criteria for inclusion of non-free content and be labeled accordingly.


 * Hook:
 * The Basic Article has a "hook" which is a one-sentence description of the articles content designed to advertise the article and make readers interested in it. The Hook must conform to the DYKJ Hook guidelines.
 * The Good Article does not require a hook unless it is to be featured at DYK
 * The Featured Article must have a one-paragraph summary that can appear on the front page when the article is featured there.