User:Marandaleesi/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluation
Germination

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose the Wikipedia article on Germination because it was interesting to me as a plant lover, especially since I struggle to germinate seeds at home. It overall appears to be very well done.

Evaluate the article
The lead section of this article is very concise and easy to understand. It has a good tone and level of simplicity that makes it easy for viewers to understand.

There is a neutral, scientific point of view on this page. There is no favoring one topic over another.

The information provided in this Wikipedia article is immense and through, but not up to date. The most recent source I saw cited was from 2012, which is over a decade ago.

All the images on this article are high quality, and follow the copyright rules existent on Wikipedia.

The talk and activity pages on this article are still active, and most of the conversation seems to be revolved around fixing up bits of the article.

Overall this article is complete and well cited. The only thing that could stand to change is to add some more recent sources than 2012 on the article.