User:MarleyMae21/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Katara (Avatar: The Last Airbender)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I picked it randomly. I used to watch the tv show as a kid, so I figured I'd have some knowledge on the information in the article already. The article is important because Katara is a central character in the tv show and books.

Evaluate the article
I thought the lead section was well done. it describes the topic of the page, gives vague details of Katara's character and is fairly concise.

I thought the content was very thorough, more thorough than I would have expected. From my knowledge on the topic, it was accurate information. I thought the information was up to date.

I thought the tone was neutral. I don't think there was really any room in this article to sway the reader on anything, it's just a character description.

The page had ample resources to back up their info.

I thought they organized it well with all of the subheadings, and it was very clear and easy to follow; no grammar errors.

The images are well captioned and even tell you what episodes they pulled them from, which I thought was nice.

The talk page has some ongoing conversations about updating the page to include the relationship she had with the main character, or including newer images, or changing a few sentences around for clarity. The article is a c-class article with mid-importance.

Overall, I think the article is well-developed. More things could be added, though, but those ideas are brought up on the talk page.