User:Marprint23/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Legendborn

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because Legendborn is a notable YA book that I read recently and that resonated with me. I also think that the article can be improved, so I'm hoping that I'm able to offer some valuable feedback.

Lead Section
The lead section of this article identifies the subject of the article with a concise and accurate first sentence ("Legendborn is a 2020 debut young adult fantasy novel by Tracy Deonn."), and the remainder of the section offers a brief plot description as well as short quotes from reviewers and notable awards. The section gives a good overview of the topic and a concise summary of the article's following sections.

Content
The article's content is relevant and accurate to the topic. The longest section is, understandably, the plot, which does make the article feel a bit top heavy. As mentioned, all of the information is accurate, but there is missing information, notably a few awards and honors that are not included in the "Accolades" section. Additionally, the "Plot" section does not encompass the entirety of the plot of the book.

Tone and Balance
Because this article is about a book, it doesn't represent an issue that has various viewpoints. The article is neutral and appropriately refers to critic response of the book.

Sources and References
The sources are up-to-date and reliable.

Organization and Writing Quality
The article is well-organized, but I wouldn't call it well-written. There are instances, especially in the plot summary, where the wording is vague and/or grammatically confusing.

Images and Media
There is only one image in the article, of the book cover. Its caption reads "First edition." This is not really a comprehensive description of the image, but in context it does make sense. The image is linked to a page citing the source and copyright owner of the image.

Talk Page Discussion
There are no ongoing discussions on the Talk Page of this article. The article is a part of the Children's literature, African diaspora, and Women writers WikiProjects.

Overall Impressions
Overall, I think the weakest part of this article is the Plot section. The rest of the article seems largely to be complete and to comprehensively cover the important points with regards to this book. It adequately summarizes critical response to the book, identifies the major awards and accolades the book has received, and includes all important information in the sidebar.