User:Mevanhoy/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Margaret Stanley (virologist)
 * Article Evaluation
 * Article's contents are relevant and do adhere to BLP policies; it does seem to be written fairly neutrally, but is generally out of date (last updates were in 2018 with last accomplishments mentioned taking place in 2017)
 * Each claim does seem to have a citation and they are generally unbiased organizations (journals, conference websites, etc)
 * Works on Wikipedia's Women scientists project
 * Talk page last updated in 2018, seemed to be concerned with notability and updates
 * Sources
 * Generally seems notable enough to have several sources
 * Sources
 * Generally seems notable enough to have several sources

Option 2 (preference)

 * Elizabeth Robertson
 * Article Evaluation
 * Article's contents are relevant and adhere to BLP policies; article is neutral, but skimp
 * Rated mid-importance, in start class
 * Claims generally have good citations
 * Works on Wikipedia's Women scientists project
 * No talk on talk page
 * Sources
 * Has fewer sources, but sources have good information
 * Sources
 * Has fewer sources, but sources have good information

Option 3 (second preference)

 * Karen Steel
 * Article Evaluation
 * Article contents are relevant and adhere to BLP policies; article is neutral but not very fleshed-out
 * Rated mid-importance, in start class
 * Claims have a few references
 * Works on Wikipedia's Women scientists project
 * No talk on talk page
 * Sources
 * Has several sources as options for expansion
 * Sources
 * Has several sources as options for expansion