User:Microbio15/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Bacteriophage

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I have chosen this article because I have done research with bacteriophage, and they are viruses, which relates to this course. Studying Bacteriophage is vital, because they can be used for therapy against drug-resistant bacteria. Good impression, the article was well written, and included many images of bacteriophage.

Evaluate the article
(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)

Lead section: Good introductory sentence, includes brief description of the major sections, it is about three short paragraphs, so not overly long.

Content: The content is relevant to the topic, it is up-to-date, not any content missing, I do not see content that deals with one of Wikipedia's equity gaps/addresses topics related to historically underrepresented populations/topics.

Tone and Balance: The article is neutral, no claims that seem to heavily bias a particular position, no attempt to persuade the reader.

Sources and References: Sources are thorough, current, and the links I clicked work.

Organization and writing quality: Article is concise and clear. I did not see any spelling errors. Well organized sections that reflect the major topic.

Images and Media: Article includes several images that enhance the topic. Some images are well captioned and detailed- describing the image such as being " an electron micrograph".

Talk page discussion: This article is part of a WikiProjects. Discussion going on include those such as removing a sentence that didn't have proper citation, citing new studies, and pointing out how some words used in the article for the first time are not explained.

Overall impressions:

This is a great article, the strengths include having a strong lead section and images that are well captioned. In the talk session somebody mentioned how this article could discuss the possible harms of phage therapy, if there are any- I agree that they should be listed in the article. The article is well-developed.