User:MikeLynch/StephenBuxtonCSDAnswers

My answers to StephenBuxton's CSD Excercises
1)User:StephenBuxton/CSD_Exercises/A_tory_liar
 * This would most likely be an attack page, in violation of WP:LIBEL, and I would have marked it with db-g10. Though this is not an article page, but a redirect, db-g10 specifies that "Both the page title and page content may be taken into account in assessing an attack", and a g10 would be appropriate. This page should be deleted, and my edit summary would read something like: "Deleted under the Criteria for Speedy Deletion under G10, as it is in violation of the Biographies of Living People policy."

2)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/Deben High School
 * A7 tagging is inappropriate, since Educational institutions are exempt from A7 provisions. The article should be kept. I would then look for reliable, verifiable sources to confirm the existence of the school, and if I am not satisfied with my search for sources, I would proceed to nominate it for deletion in order to gather community input on whether this might have been a hoax.

3)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/Malcom Hardee
 * G10 tagging is appropriate, since this is an attack page. The page should be deleted. My deletion summary would read "Deleted under the Criteria for Speedy Deletion under G10, as it is in violation of the Biographies of Living People policy.".

4)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/New article
 * For this, G2 tagging would be more appropriate, and I would have marked it with db-g2. This page is apparently a test page, given the title and contents. It should be deleted, and my deletion summary would be something like "Deleted under the Criteria for Speedy Deletion under G2, as it is a test page.".

5)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/Wizzy Wig the Clown
 * This does not fall under A7, as the article makes a clear claim of significance. The article should not be deleted. I would then make a search for sources, and then decide whether to go for AfD or not.

6)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/Athur the Great
 * This would clearly fall under A7, because the article makes no mention as to why the subject is significant. This page should be deleted. My deletion summary would read something like: "Deleted under the Criteria for Speedy Deletion under A7, as it does not indicate why it is important.".

7)User:StephenBuxton/CSD Exercises/Sudar Barash
 * The article makes a claim of significance, and hence, tagging for CSD under A7 is inappropriate. The page should not be deleted. The username User:Acme engineering seems to be a WP:UPOL violation, and I would report it to WP:UAA.

Thank you,  Lynch 7  12:54, 14 January 2012 (UTC)