User:Moonhater99/Sextus Tarquinius/Bruisingspace01 Peer Review

Peer review
This is where you will complete your peer review exercise. Please use the following template to fill out your review.

General info

 * Moonhater99
 * User:Moonhater99/Sextus Tarquinius

Lead
Guiding questions:


 * The lead has not been updated.
 * The lead provides a good introduction to what the article is about.
 * The lead includes a small summary of one of the sections, but doesn't cover the other section.
 * The lead contains information that relates to Sextus Tarquinius' life that is not found elsewhere in the article. If you're looking for ways to improve the article, I'd suggest looking into his early life! (if at all possible; I totally get that certain sources like to omit information about historical figures or that sometimes researching certain information is fruitless)
 * The lead is concise, but could be updated a little bit.

Lead evaluation
Take a look back at your lead! I didn't even rework my lead for my article, but it would be a good idea to go back to yours once you've finished reworking the article just to update it with what you've personally done (if not to update what the previous editors have done).

Content
Guiding questions:


 * The only new things added to the article were links to other pages and a work of art relating to the topic. Nice job linking everything, especially without overdoing it! I will note that you did link Collatinus twice, whether on accident or on purpose, but I just wanted to make you aware of that.
 * I don't see any new sources, but I'm sure that would change as you furthered your research.
 * I would have liked to see some information on his early life, but I know how hard it can be to find reliable sources from not only the time in which he lived, but the secondary sources that would come afterwards.
 * The topic doesn't represent a group, person, or topic that is underrepresented.

Content evaluation
I think what you added link-wise was great (creating rabbit holes for people to fall down into! Yay!), but it would be good for you to focus on Sextus Tarquinius himself instead of focusing mainly on his rape of Lucretia because the way the article is set up (and I 100% know that this isn't your fault at all) steers the conversation to being about Sextus and Lucretia instead of having the article be who it's supposed to be about, which is Sextus. So try to focus on making the conversation about Sextus and maybe find an image or two with just him as the subject? I know researching can be the bane of our existence, but you got this!

Tone and Balance
Guiding questions:


 * The links and image are neutral, yes.
 * Are there any claims that appear heavily biased toward a particular position?
 * Are there viewpoints that are overrepresented, or underrepresented?
 * Does the content added attempt to persuade the reader in favor of one position or away from another?

Tone and balance evaluation
As previously stated (so I won't get super detailed about it), I definitely feel that you could steer the balance away from solely Lucretia's rape and art including the both of them to Sextus' early life and living in his father's court and serving in the military. I know information like that is hard to come by, but try to keep in mind that this isn't an article about Sextus AND Lucretia.

Sources and References
Guiding questions:


 * N/A
 * N/A
 * N/A
 * N/A
 * The links work!

Sources and references evaluation
I can't really discuss sources if there aren't any new ones to comment on.

Organization
Guiding questions:


 * The links go straight to the pages they are supposed to.
 * No errors of any kind.
 * The major points of this topic are few and far in between - be sure to work on that and the article will surely improve!

Images and Media
Guiding questions: If your peer added images or media


 * The article includes images that pertain to a section of the article.
 * The image has no caption underneath the picture, but one is there when the image itself is clicked on.
 * Yes! The image added follows the copyrighting and the licensing.
 * The image would be added to the article in a way that would further demonstrate the point of the section that it belongs to.

Images and media evaluation
I would really like to see Sextus portrayed in art in his earlier stages of life! I feel like that would make him more rounded as a person instead of just solely defining him as Lucretia's rapist (even though what he did to her was incredibly heinous).

Overall impressions
Guiding questions:


 * The article does feel more complete and put together now that more links to other pages have been put in.
 * Nothing new has really been added, but the improvement of what was there is really good!
 * With what you've added thus far, the only thing I would do to improve it is just to add a snazzy caption for your image!

Overall evaluation
What you've done so far is good! Keep it up! I know doing hours of research is extremely tedious and can make the eyes go blurry. It would be great for the article to include more about Sextus' life (which I recognize I'm saying for probably the 87th time), but other than that good work!