User:Movingqlong/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Carbonyl metallurgy
 * - The content is relevant
 * - Content is neutrally written
 * - No in-text citations
 * - Since there are no in-text citations, current sources will need to be checked and new sources found to corroborate information
 * - The article has interesting content and states that the chemistry may be useful in the future
 * - The Talk page mentions that the source links were broken then fixed. However, that was from 2014, so the links may be broken again
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.

Option 2

 * Carbene dye
 * - The content is relevant
 * - The content is written neutrally
 * - No in-text citations
 * - The sources are from reliable sources but are >15 years old; hopefully there will be recent research/information on the topic
 * - Carbene chemistry is an interesting part of inorganic chemistry, so using them as dyes sounds very interesting!
 * - There are no discussions on the Talk Page
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.

Option 3

 * Ionic crystal
 * - The content is relevant
 * - The article employs a neutral voice
 * - Citations were retrieved from webpages more than 10 years ago; content may have been updated since then
 * - One my Chem courses actually asked about ionic crystals on a problem set, so yes the material is very relevant and it's important to have updated information!
 * - The Talk page discusses improving the article or stubbing it down completely to one sentence
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.
 * Sources
 * None, at the moment.

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Article Evaluation
 * Sources
 * Sources
 * Sources