User:Ninaanastasio/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Culture and the Arts -- Celebrity doctors
 * Article Evaluation
 * - The content is relevant, but the information is limited
 * - Should focus on the impact they have on the culture
 * - The content is relevant
 * - Most of the sources are from journal articles
 * - Each claim does have a citation
 * - This topic has not be added to in 5 years
 * - It is an article of interest to WikiProjects
 * - Start-class rating for medicine, alternative medicine and scepticism
 * - Start-class rating for medicine, alternative medicine and scepticism


 * Sources
 * Celebrity doctor

Option 2

 * Celebrity privacy
 * Article Evaluation
 * Article Evaluation

- Not all sources are from journal or credible sources

- This article has multiple issues and has a rating of C

- This article in an orphan and requires links to be attached to it

- This article is written as a personal reflection and needs to be changed

- This is within the scope of WikiProject Media


 * Sources
 * Celebrity privacy

Option 3

 * Plastic Surgery
 * Article Evaluation
 * - Has been rated B class
 * - High importance for medicine and medium importance for psychology
 * - Does not meet the requirement of good article criteria and needs changes
 * - Within the scope of WikiProjects medicine, body modification, psychology and history
 * - More citing needs to be done within the article
 * Sources
 * Plastic surgery
 * Sources
 * Plastic surgery
 * Plastic surgery

Option 4

 * Infomercial
 * Article Evaluation
 * - Lots of citations needed throughout the article
 * - Rated C-class
 * - This is top importance under WikiProjects Marketing & Advertisement
 * - Marked medium importance under WikiProject Television
 * Sources
 * Infomercial
 * Sources
 * Infomercial

Option 5

 * Publication
 * Article Evaluation
 * - Mentions for 10 WikiProjects all in start-class, most with high importance
 * - Needs more sources
 * - Has not been contributed to in around 5 years
 * - It needs additional citations for verification
 * - The examples may not show a worldwide view
 * Sources
 * Publication
 * Sources
 * Publication