User:Nixeagle/RFA

Problems with RFA in my view.


 * 1) There are no set minimum requirements, just community expectation. This is very hard to read and shifts back and forth between allowing "wikignome" style admins and "article writer" style admins.
 * !votes based on FA's or lack thereof.
 * speculative !votes

possible requirements

 * We innately expect X votes, why not set this as a minimum requirement. I suppose X should be in the range of 1000 to 3000. I have never seen a canidate in recent times get passed without at least 2000 edits.
 * We expect X amount of time on the project. again why not set this as a minimum requirement. say 2 months on the project. I have never seen anyone pass with less then 2 months in recent times.