User:Nosebagbear/Arbcom notes

Wikipedia talk:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Iranian politics/Evidence
Firstly, I respect [Courtesy ping] a great deal, and this isn't designed to be a negative position towards them.

That said, I am somewhat questioning their evidence.

Absolutely civil-POV pushing does happen and likely is happening here.

However I find their basis of microaggression evidence here is distinctly questionable. The majority of these statements you'd see with large numbers of admins questioning editors committing what I might call dubious edits - instances the editor could, in good-faith, come to that conclusion from the nature of the editing.

Now comments like I am against CRP violation and I have reported Idealigic for this. As for the IP's edit, before any revert, there should be substantiated objection from Idealigic which is missing here. [...] The materials being supported by this edit are falsely challenged by Idealigic et al. So, addition of a citation is quite OK. are somewhat more clear, and perhaps as a combined mass with comments like that, they could somewhat demonstrate a pattern, but I definitely feel this particular batch of evidence is not clear-cut. Nosebagbear (talk) 22:15, 11 August 2021 (UTC)