User:OlYeller21/Case Studies/Carbonator

Summary
This is my own account. I've left out diffs to keep this short. The evidence can be found below. Ol Yeller '''Talktome 22:48, 28 June 2011 (UTC)
 * I ran into Carbonator at Everybody Draw Mohammed Day. He was attempting to change the description of the event to annual and when he was confronted by other editors, including myself, the wheels began to fall off.  At first, Carbonator was uncivil.  Then, through some coaxing, started engaging in a conversation on the talk page.  He felt that I was being condescending despite my attempt to assure him that I meant no ill will.  Admittedly, I sometimes run into the issue when trying to find the compromise between getting my point across and not writing 40 pages to do so.  After only providing two references which other editors, including myself, did not find substantial enough to warrant changing the description, things got worse.  Carbonator started leaving vulgar messages on his talk page for me, socking to avoid blocks and in an attempt to bolster his argument, and then edit warring.  After several blocks and the passing of the would-be anniversary of the EDMD event, he disappeared only to reappear as a sock and attempt to have a page I created, speedily deleted.  I initiated a CheckUser via an admin I talked to on IRC.  It resulted in an indefinite ban. I've created this listing after the indefinite ban for use at a later time, if necessary.  Ol Yeller  '''Talktome 22:48, 28 June 2011 (UTC)

Notes/Observations

 * Seems to mostly edit pages dealing with Islam and controversies dealing with Muslims and Islam
 * Often edits BLP's infobox and changes the stated religion to say "none" instead of "Agnostic" or "Atheist"
 * Sometimes edits pages dealing with other religions besides Islam
 * Edits pages that deal with the perceived teachings of South Park episodes
 * Often makes buffer edits to, I assume, avoid looking like an WP:SPA by changing hyphens in articles
 * Removes warning from talk page as quickly as possible but leaves one low level warning to, I assume, make it look like he's only been warned once

Articles paid most attention

 * Everybody Draw Mohammed Day
 * 201 (South Park)
 * Criticism of Muhammad
 * Barbara Boxer
 * Ayman al-Zawahiri
 * Billy Graham


 * Adding Depictions of Muhammad in See Also section of articles - SallySE  Carbonator
 * POV pushing - ,,,,
 * Mirrored arguments while evading block - SallySE,Carbonator
 * When confronted, openly stated that not only was this not a sock, he didn't even know what a sock was - SallySE


 * I never ran into this sock.
 * Pushed the same POV edits at Ayman al-Zawahiri and 201 (South Park)


 * Obvious sock. Has been blocked.


 * Blanked a page that I created and listed as having created on my User page -

Confirmed via CheckUser
As ✅ by CheckUser as the same person:

Incivility

 * Called me a little thin-skinned prick
 * Told me to fuck off
 * Slowly rebuilds the first message to, I assume, make jabs at me -
 * Told the blocking admin to fuck off

Hounding

 * Reverts a uncontroversial edit as vandalism at a page I created and have listed as creating on my user page -
 * Attempted to have the same page speedily deleted under a general DB tag -
 * After another user changed the DB to a prod, I declined the prod. SallySE then reapplied the DB tag -
 * After an admin declined the speedy, Bernin18 (a sock) replaced the DB tag -
 * Blanked a page that I created and listed as having created on my User page -

Other history

 * Reported at AIV on May 20, 2011 which resulted in a 1 week block -

Conclusion

 * This editor has been indefinitely blocked from WP after an SPI was done by that I initiated in the IRC English Help channel.  Ol Yeller  '''Talktome 17:35, 28 June 2011 (UTC)
 * Has had talk page privelidges revoked due to creating an inflammatory user page and talk page message. Ol Yeller  '''Talktome 22:52, 28 June 2011 (UTC)