User:Omni ND/Tropical Cyclone Analysis/Category 5 Or Not?

This page analyzes North Atlantic tropical cyclones that may have been Category 5's.

Indianola Hurricane of 1886
This tropical cyclone was at the very threshold of Category 5 intensity, but is listed at 135 knots. However, it was intensifying up until landfall and had no measurements near the core.

Verdict: 75% Category 5

Hurricane San Ciracao
The maximum sustained winds of this tropical cyclone were held at 130 knots as it made landfall on Puerto Rico. Data shows that it never restrengthened into a Category 4 hurricane. Also, 930 mbar is a bit too high for a Category 5 hurricane.

Verdict: 10% Category 5

Hurricane 5 of 1910
This hurricane had maximum sustained winds of 130 knots, but a minimum central pressure of 924 mbar. Also, it reached its maximum intensity while near Cuba.

Verdict: 30% Category 5