User:Orfen/RfA and XfD Contributions

Inspired by Cynical's user subpage this is a subpage with easy access to the different decisions I have made along with the outcome of said discussions. I do this to allow users easy access to the decisions I have made in the past and the reasons for these decisions. I think by doing this I can provide increased transparency of the contributions I have made to both RfA and XfD. This is also to help me see some of the ways I have gone about things in the past and help me improve upon things. All contributions are listed in chronological order with the oldest contributions first.

RfA

 * Total:
 * Number of Support: 77
 * Number of Oppose: 34
 * Number of Neutral: 8


 * Total Successful: 76
 * Total Unsuccessful: 45

XfD

 * Total:
 * Number of Keep: 10
 * Number of Delete: 29
 * Number of Other : 4

Support

 * 1) Metros232 {successful)
 * 2) Tango (successful)
 * 3) Gnangarra (successful)
 * 4) Dina (successful)
 * 5) Can't sleep, clown will eat me Arbitration Committee Elections December 2006 (unsuccessful)
 * 6) Shirahadasha 2nd Nomination (successful)
 * 7) TerriersFan (successful)
 * 8) Ragesoss (successful)
 * 9) Badlydrawnjeff 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 10) AndonicO (successful)
 * 11) Mallanox (successful)
 * 12) Sam Blacketer (successful)
 * 13) Krimpet (successful)
 * 14) Adambro (successful)
 * 15) Scientizzle (successful)
 * 16) Bibliomaniac15 (successful)
 * 17) Selket (successful)
 * 18) Matt Britt 2nd Nomination (successful)
 * 19) Prolog (successful)
 * 20) TwinsMetsFan (successful)
 * 21) Stephen (successful)
 * 22) The Rambling Man (successful)
 * 23) Errabee (did not succeed)
 * 24) AGK (successful)
 * 25) Sr13 (successful)
 * 26) Eyrian (successful)
 * 27) DGG (successful)
 * 28) Slumgum (successful)
 * 29) MastCell (successful)
 * 30) BigrTex (successful)
 * 31) David Fuchs (successful)
 * 32) Moreschi 2nd Nomination (successful)
 * 33) CattleGirl (successful)
 * 34) MZMcBride (successful)
 * 35) Rettetast (successful)
 * 36) Pastordavid (successful)
 * 37) Dekimasu (successful)
 * 38) Searchme (successful)
 * 39) Seattle Skier (successful)
 * 40) AQu01rius (successful)
 * 41) After Midnight (successful)
 * 42) Ikiroid 2nd Nomination (successful)
 * 43) Dweller (successful)
 * 44) Khukri 2 (successful)
 * 45) BrendelSignature (successful)
 * 46) Cecropia 2nd RfB Nomination (successful)
 * 47) C.Fred (successful)
 * 48) Anas Salloum (successful)
 * 49) Masamage (successful)
 * 50) Maxsem (successful)
 * 51) Carioca (successful)
 * 52) Audacity (successful)
 * 53) Alvestrand (successful)
 * 54) Lucasbfr (successful)
 * 55) Arctic.gnome (successful)
 * 56) Nihiltres (successful)
 * 57) Yonatan (successful)
 * 58) Akradecki (successful)
 * 59) Bobak (successful)
 * 60) Yamamoto Ichiro (successful)
 * 61) Spurious (successful)
 * 62) PeaceNT (successful)
 * 63) Booksworm (did not succeed)
 * 64) Ocatecir (successful)
 * 65) Christopher Parham (successful)
 * 66) Pascal.Tesson 2nd Nomination (successful)
 * 67) The Transhumanist 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 68) DanMS (successful)
 * 69) Vassyana (successful)
 * 70) WilyD (successful)
 * 71) Bedford (successful)
 * 72) RyanLupin 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 73) Cailil (successful)
 * 74) StephenBuxton (successful)
 * 75) Matthewedwards (successful)
 * 76) Happyme22 (successful)
 * 77) PresN (successful)
 * 78) Panyd 2nd Nomination (successful)

Oppose

 * 1) Doctor Evil (did not succeed)
 * 2) MoRsE (did not succeed)
 * 3) DavidJJJ (did not succeed)
 * 4) Hello32020 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 5) SteveBaker (did not succeed)
 * 6) Lllama man (did not succeed)
 * 7) TonyTheTiger 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 8) the juggsd86 (did not succeed)
 * 9) Max Naylor (did not succeed)
 * 10) Nima Baghaei 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 11) Retiono Virginian (did not succeed)
 * 12) Martinultima (did not succeed)
 * 13) Bloodpack (did not succeed)
 * 14) SFGiants (did not succeed)
 * 15) G1ggy (did not succeed)
 * 16) Jhfireboy (did not succeed)
 * 17) Pupster21 (did not succeed)
 * 18) Nenyedi (did not succeed)
 * 19) PeeJay2K3 (did not succeed)
 * 20) StephenHjellum (did not succeed)
 * 21) Dynaflow (did not succeed)
 * 22) Nardman1 (did not succeed)
 * 23) Roastytoast (did not succeed)
 * 24) Tenebrae 2nd Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 25) Bjelleklang (successful)
 * 26) N734LQ (did not succeed)
 * 27) TenPoundHammer (did not succeed)
 * 28) Marcschulz (did not succeed)
 * 29) Redfarmer (did not succeed)
 * 30) The Transhumanist 5th Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 31) Tkgd2007 (did not succeed)
 * 32) Ilyushka88 (did not succeed)
 * 33) Headbomb (did not succeed)
 * 34) Golich17 (did not succeed)

Neutral

 * 1) Moralis (did not succeed)
 * 2) Eukesh (did not succeed)
 * 3) Slgrandson (did not succeed)
 * 4) Dark Dragon Flame (did not succeed)
 * 5) Blueboy96 (did not succeed)
 * 6) William Pietri (successful)
 * 7) Benon 6th Nomination (did not succeed)
 * 8) LessHeard vanU (successful)

Keep

 * 1) Letterbomb (speedy redirect to Mailbomb)
 * 2) Items in the Metroid series (keep)
 * 3) Give 'Em Hell, Kid (keep)
 * 4) American Idiot (film) (delete for now)
 * 5) Jason Freese (keep)
 * 6) The End. (relisting in individual AFDs)
 * 7) Eddy (Ed, Edd n Eddy) (keep)
 * 8) Henry Potty and the Pet Rock (keep)
 * 9) Template:User vandalized (withdrawn by nominator)
 * 10) Atomic bombings of Japan as a form of state terrorism (2nd nomination) (no consensus to delete defaulting to keep)

Delete

 * 1) The Patient (delete)
 * 2) List of characters in fighting games (delete)
 * 3) Under pressure (my chem & the used song) (delete)
 * 4) Star wars (fan film) (delete)
 * 5) Tommy Gun (Green Day album) (delete)
 * 6) RuneScape mini-games (delete)
 * 7) Rayfield (band) (delete)
 * 8) Filming mistakes from That's So Raven (delete)
 * 9) Crown Tranceiver (delete all)
 * 10) Numbers in music (deleted)
 * 11) Astro Empires (deleted)
 * 12) Wikipedia:WikiProject RuneScape (no concensus-default keep)
 * 13) Wikipedia:Esperanza (decentralize Esperanza)
 * 14) The Patient (2nd nomination) (keep)
 * 15) Servers of City of Heroes and City of Villains (delete)
 * 16) Astro Zombies EP (delete)
 * 17) Starships! (regular delete)
 * 18) Sleep (My Chemical Romance song) (redirect back to The Black Parade)
 * 19) User:Cyberoidx/cbvsreal (withdrawn)
 * 20) My Chemical Romance's Upcoming Fourth Studio Album (delete)
 * 21) Bunnies (song) (delete)
 * 22) Evolver (John Legend album) (delete)
 * 23) The Sly Serpent (delete)
 * 24) American Idiots: The Motion Picture (redirect to American Idiot#Movie adaptation)
 * 25) Sorry (Jonas Brothers song) (delete)
 * 26) Shelf (Jonas Brothers song) (delete)
 * 27) Love Bug (Jonas Brothers song) (delete without prejudice)
 * 28) BugJuice (delete)
 * 29) Apple and Cinnamon (Utada Hikaru song) (delete)

Other

 * 1) It's Not a Fashion Statement, It's a Deathwish (redirect)
 * 2) Anic (redirected)
 * 3) Myspace Girl (delete)
 * 4) 1998 demo tape (redirect/merge)