User:Paintedsakura/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title:Talk: Koi
 * Article Evaluation:Solid base, but many things seem repetitive or redundant. Can definitely be more organized, maybe user have conflicting views. There doe not seem to be a flow or sense of organization to the page. The content does seem to be relevant for the most part. The tone of the article is also neutral. Sources are definitely missing.
 * Sources:One sources they can look into for more information about the Japanese koi is from the Smithsonian Zoo :https://nationalzoo.si.edu/animals/japanese-koi

Option 2

 * Article title:Talk: Valorant
 * Article Evaluation:The article is messy, although it appears it is used mostly as practice, just like this. Although content does relate to the topic, it feels more like a social media thread rather than a Wikipedia article. The actual information about the game has a neutral tone. Lacks citations, but the existing citations are reliable, although they are primary sources.
 * Sources:Potential sources may include blog or articles relating to game news that updates players on new and relevant information about the game.

Option 3

 * Article title:Hololive Production
 * Article Evaluation:The article is written in a neutral tone. The content is well organized and relevant to the topic. The information is detailed but not overly dense. It keeps the readers up to date with major issues, but not so much so that it feels more like a social thread of updates. All information does have a citation and the citations appear to be reliable.
 * Sources:Can check up on articles dedicated to updating and writing about this production.

Option 4

 * Article title:Digimon Adventure ( 1999 TV series)
 * Article Evaluation:The content is informative and relevant to the topic. It is also written in a neutral tone. Provides plenty of hyperlinks that offer more information that not entirely relevant to the specific topic. Information has citations, and the citations are also reliable.
 * Sources:Plenty of outside sources that relate to this topic. Potentially look for articles that provide information about this topic.

Option 5

 * Article title:Horse
 * Article Evaluation:The content is written in a neutral tone. The content is relevant to the topic and also provides hyperlinks for more detailed and specialized information about the topic. Each claim does have a citation and the citations are reliable.
 * Sources:I do not believe I can find more sources for this topic as there is a lot of detailed information that cover most bases of this topic. If I were to look for other sources, I believe I can find many scientific journals and research about this topic.