User:Pan Někdo/sandbox

Which cities should be included?
Currently there is no clear approach to cities in Caucasus (Tbilisi, Baku, Yerevan) and it causes edit wars. There has been a lot of discussion about it here but it's too long to read and despite the lenght it gives no clear guidelines about their inclusion/exclusion. So I think we should solve it once and for all. In the end it should end up in FAQ as Istanbul ended.

The only consensus in the discussion is that if they are included they should have a note stating it's unclear if they are in Europe. But still it doesn't make it much clearer: should we include only one, or two, or all? Should we include them in the main table or should we make another table for them? If we include them in the main table should we rank them or let them unranked? Amd if you can think of any other possibility add it here as well.

Here are my opinions: We should include them all or exclude them all (I am in favor of excluding them all). There is only one definition that puts some of them to Europe and some of them to Asia and it even isn't a very popular definition. I don't think we can say their culture is European or Asian without saying the countries are European/Asian in the first place so I don't think argumentation about their culture is of much value.

I don't think it's good idea to put them in separate table or at the end of the table. However, I can imagine to include them without ranking.

--Pan Někdo (talk) 20:25, 17 November 2022 (UTC) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Pan_N%C4%9Bkdo/sandbox