User:Pharmacy03/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
99 Luftballons

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I have always enjoyed this song, and while I knew it was anti-war I didn't know anymore specifics than that.

Evaluate the article
The overall content is appropriate and has a logical flow.

The tone of the article remains generally neutral. However, there does seem to be a preference of the original German song over the English version. This can be seen in the quotes of the original German band giving their slightly negative opinions on the English version, but there are no quotes that are in support of this version.

This article has sources for each fact the put in. However, some of the links bring you to a "not found" page. The links that do work bring you to sites that seems to be reliable and unbiased. This is most likely due to the older nature of the article, but some of the sources lead to websites that appear to be from the early 2000s and haven't been updated since.

The talk page shows people are mostly discussing things like references of the song in other places, and large implications of the song. This article is rated C-Class, and is apart of the wikiproject Songs.