User:Quintenvdw/sandbox

Which article are you evaluating?
Gush Emunim

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article since it is related to the topic of sectarianism, which Ussama Makdissi defines as the 'deployment of religious heritage as a primary marker of political identity'. Additionally, it is a subject I would consider myself to be knowledgable of, without which it would be rather difficult to evaluate. Gush Emunim as a messianic organization that instrumentalizes religion for political purposes, thus fits the sectarian picture quite well. My preliminary of the article was that it is short, but the list of sources appears to be well-founded and thorough nevertheless.

Evaluate the article
(Compose a detailed evaluation of the article here, considering each of the key aspects listed above. Consider the guiding questions, and check out the examples of what a useful Wikipedia article evaluation looks like.)

The LEAD of the article is concise: it grasps the main goal of Gush Emunim rather well, whilst simultaneously addressing its influence on Israeli society. As for the CONTENT, there appears to be a wide gap. The subsection dealing with the history of the movement jumps from 1976 to 2017, thus skipping four decades. This is a shame, because the influence of the movement was particularly vast during the 1980s (evidenced by the election of Meir Kahane in the Knesset) and the 1990s. the TONE AND BALANCE appears to be in order. The article (very) briefly summarizes the manner in which the movement is described, without emphasizing one or the other. Recent work of Sivan Hirsch-Hoefler and Cas Mudde is not yet included, but given the publication date of their work (November 2020) that is understandable. Overall, the SOURCES AND REFERENCES are in order. My main comment would be that there a references to pages (mostly persons) without an active Wikipedia page, which is distracting. The ORGANIZATION AND WRITING QUALITY is alright. I think the article could benefit from a section specifically addressing the movement's impact on Israeli society and the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, but I admit that this would make it vulnerable to accusations of partiality. Furthermore, as already addressed, the history subsection is incomplete. The article does not contain IMAGES AND MEDIA. There are no issues that addressed on the TALK PAGE DISCUSSION that were not already covered above. Finally, the OVERALL IMPRESSION is that the lead is good, but the remainder of the article does not live up to the information available on Gush Emunim. Therefore, this article would be an excellent article to edit, expand.

Paragraph: Set the style of your text. For example, make a header or plain paragraph text. You can also use it to offset block quotes.
 A  : Highlight your text, then click here to format it with bold, italics, etc. The “More” options allows you to underline (U), cross-out text ( S ), add code snippets ( { } ), change language keyboards (Aあ), and clear all formatting.

Links: Highlight text and push this button to make it a link. The Visual Editor will automatically suggest related Wikipedia articles for that word or phrase. This is a great way to connect your article to more Wikipedia content. You only have to link important words once, usually during the first time they appear. If you want to link to pages outside of Wikipedia (for an “external links” section, for example) click on the “External link” tab.

Cite : The citation tool in the Visual Editor helps format your citations. You can simply paste a DOI or URL, and the Visual Editor will try to sort out all of the fields you need. Be sure to review it, however, and apply missing fields manually (if you know them). You can also add books, journals, news, and websites manually. That opens up a quick guide for inputting your citations. Once you've added a source, you can click the “re-use” tab to cite it again.


 * Bullets: To add bullet points or a numbered list, click here.

Insert : This tab lets you add media, images, or tables.

Ω: This tab allows you to add special characters, such as those found in non-English words, scientific notation, and a handful of language extensions.محمد بن سلمان

bold

bold

= Gush Emunim edits =

Gush Emunim (Hebrew: גּוּשׁ אֱמוּנִים‎‎, Bloc of the Faithful) was an Israeli Orthodox Jewish right-wing activist movement committed to establishing Jewish settlements in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, and the Golan Heights. While not formally established as an organization until 1974 in the wake of the Yom Kippur War, Gush Emunim sprang out of the conquests of the Six-Day War in 1967, encouraging Jewish settlement of the land based on the belief that, according to the Torah, God gave it to the Jewish people. While Gush Emunim no longer exists officially, vestiges of its influence remain in Israeli society.

Contents

 * 1Political affiliations
 * 2History
 * 3Ideology
 * 4See also
 * 5Notes
 * 6External links

Political affiliations[edit]
Gush Emunim was closely associated with, and highly influential in, the National Religious Party (NRP). Nowadays, they refer to themselves - and are referred to by the Israeli media - as Ne'emanei Eretz Yisrael נאמני ארץ ישראל‎ (English: "Those who are loyal/faithful to the Land of Israel"). It also had a close relationship with the Jewish Agency.

History[edit]
Gush Emunim was founded by students of Rabbi Tzvi Yehuda Kook in February 1974 in the living room of Haim Drukman, who is also credited with coining the term. ''' For the founders of the organization, the Yom Kippur War confirmed what Tzvi Yehuda Kook already argued before the outbreak of the Six-Day War: that Jewish settlement was required to hasten the process of redemption. ''' In addition to Drukman, its ideological and political core consisted of other disciples such as Hanan Porat, Moshe Levinger, Shlomo Aviner, Menachem Froman, Eliezer Waldman, Yoel Ben-Nun, and Yaakov Ariel. Kook remained its leader until his death in 1982.

In late 1974, an affiliated group named Garin Elon Moreh, led by Rabbi Menachem Felix and Benjamin (Beni) Katzover, attempted to establish a settlement on the ruins of the Sebastia train station dating from the Ottoman period. After seven attempts and six removals from the site by the Israel Defense Forces, an agreement was reached according to which the Israeli government allowed 25 families to settle in the Kadum army camp southwest of Nablus/Shechem. The Sebastia agreement was a turning point that opened up the northern West Bank to Jewish settlement. The small mobile home site housing 25 families eventually became the municipality of Kedumim, one of the major settlements in the West Bank. The Sebastia model was subsequently copied in Beit El, Shavei Shomron, and other settlements.

In 1976, Gush Emunim founded the settlement-building arm Amana, which soon became independent and is still active. ''' In 1979-80, a group of members from Gush Emunim radicalised and formed the Jewish Underground. This organization conducted several terror attacks and plotted to blow up the Dome of the Rock.   The uncovering of the terrorist organization led to a severe blow to the settler movement's reputation. Following the crisis, Gush Emunim's role as the formal umbrella organization of the settler movement was gradually taken over by the Yesha Council, although Gush Emunim never formally ceased to exist.   Despite being rooted in Gush Emunim, the Yesha Council is considered more practical and pragmatic than its predecessor.  T he Yesha Council, in its role as the political umbrella organization, and Amana, as the executive, settler-building branch, nowadays form the two main institutions of the settler movement. '''

Ideology[edit]
The ideological outlook of Gush Emunim has been described as messianic, fundamentalist, theocratic, and right-wing. Its beliefs were based heavily on the teachings of Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and his son, Rabbi Tzvi Yehuda Kook, who taught that secular Zionists, through their conquests of Eretz Israel, had unwittingly brought about the beginning of the Messianic Age, which would culminate in the coming of the messiah, which Gush Emunim supporters believe can be hastened through Jewish settlement on land they believe God has allotted to the Jewish people as set forth in the Hebrew Bible. The organization supported attempts to co-exist with the Arab population, rejecting the population transfers proposed by Meir Kahane and his followers.

Political impact
''' The overall practical aim of preventing territorial compromise and annexation of occupied territories has only partly been accomplished. Prominent failures include the demolishing and evacuation of settlements in the Sinai peninsula following the Camp David Accords, the phased transfer of jurisdiction to the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank as part of the Oslo Accords, and the 2005 Gaza Disengagement. '''

''' Gush Emunim and its successors have successfully attracted billions of US dollars for the building and supporting of settlements. The 2005 Sasson Report revealed that the Ministry of Housing, the Ministry of Defense and the World Zionist Organization spent millions of shekels to support illegal outposts. Between 2013 and 2015, Amana received government funding of approximately 100 million shekels ($29 million).   On 31 December 2019, the Israeli High Court of Justice decided that any government donations to the executive branch of the settler movement required approval from the court. '''

''' The settler movement has successfully appealed to sentiments related to Israeli identity, making it difficult for government officials and political leaders on the right to distance themselves from the settlers. Support for the settlement project has become mainstream in the US Republican Party, and almost all parties on the right of the political spectrum in Israel have settlers within its leadership.   Settlers have been disproportionately represented in government positions. The 2013 government was dubbed the 'settler government' in a Haaretz editorial, due to the amount of officials associated with the settler movement in powerful positions within the ministries of Housing and Defense. ''' In October 2017, under the leadership of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Pinchas Wallerstein, one of the founders of Gush Emunim, was appointed to head a new government committee created for the purpose of legalising illegal outposts and other types of unauthorised settlements in the West Bank.

Societal impact
''' The establishment of Gush Emunim correlated with the revival of the Greater Israel ideology within the national religious community.   The settler movement is also accused of provoking a culture of violence, with the Israeli government condoning its actions.   The perpetrator of the 1994 Hebron massacre as well as the assassinator of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin were proponents of the Greater Israel ideology, with the latter being educated in the Gush Emunim-oriented Yeshivat Kerem B'Yavneh. The murder of Yitzak Rabin is widely regarded to have been a breaking point in the Oslo peace process. '''

''' Since the founding of Gush Emunim in 1974, the amount of settlers living in the West Bank has grown from close to zero in 1974 to approximately 440,000 in 2019. The amount of settlements ultimo 2020 stood at 132, and the number of illegal outposts at 135. '''

See also[edit]

 * Menachem Froman
 * Israeli settlements
 * Jewish fundamentalism
 * Jewish Underground, a Jewish terrorist organization formed by prominent members of Gush Emunim
 * Tzvi Yehuda Kook
 * Moshe Levinger
 * Moledet
 * Orthodox Judaism
 * Temple Mount and Eretz Yisrael Faithful Movement
 * Terror Against Terror