User:RKM757/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Article 1 Title: Biometrics in Schools

Article Evaluation

Relevance

This article’s content is relevant to the topic as it discusses using biometrics in schools. The article describes how biometrics are used in school, the types applied, and how different nations, including the UK and Belgium, apply biometrics in schools.

Neutrality

The article is written neutrally as it does not only discuss the strengths of biometrics in school but also the limitations, including privacy concerns.

Citations

There are numerous citations throughout the article. These citations are accessible as they are highlighted and redirect readers to the sources once clicked upon. Most citations are reliable since they involve reputable organizations like the Department of Education. Readers can also verify information from these citations by comparing them to other sources.

Wikipedia’s Equity Gap

Technology is a highly misrepresented subject; hence, the article tackles one of Wikipedia’s equity gaps by addressing biometrics in schools.

Talk Page

In the article’s Talk Page, other Wikipedians discuss the challenges of biometrics in schools, including privacy violations and misconceptions regarding this technology. I would also post my ideas on similar concepts to ensure readers understand the subject well.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biometrics_in_schools

Article 2 Title: Mobile Security

Article Evaluation

Relevance

The content of this article is relevant to the topic as it includes security threats to mobile phones. The article discusses, in detail, numerous security threats that mobile phone users could experience and provides relevant examples.

Neutrality

One aspect that shows that the article is written neutrally is that it includes both arguments for mobile security threats and arguments against them. The article does not lean towards a particular perspective but discusses each threat according to the available publications and evidence.

Citations

The article involves numerous citations from articles, books, and websites. These sources are reliable as experts write them, and their information can be easily verified.

Wikipedia’s Equity Gaps

Technology is a highly misrepresented subject; hence, by addressing issues related to mobile security, the article does a great job of tackling one of Wikipedia’s equity gaps.

Talk Page

In the article’s Talk Page, other Wikipedians have translated the article into French and provided additional information, such as classifying hackers and identifying flaws with the article’s content. I would contribute to this page by exploring mobile security threats more.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_security

Article 3 Title: Digital Divide in the US

Article Evaluation

Relevance

The details of this article are relevant to the topic as they describe inequalities in access to information and communication technologies. The article looks into how majority and minority groups are divided by their level of access to digital devices.

Neutrality

This article is written neutrally, including numerous statistics to support its conclusions. Rather than providing personal opinions, the article looks at the facts and data involving access to digital communication devices between minority and majority groups.

Citations

Numerous citations are spread throughout each section of the article. These citations are reliable since they include reputable organizations and expert authors. Information from these citations can also be verified.

Wikipedia’s Equity Gaps

This article tackles historically underrepresented groups, including racial and ethnic minorities and women, regarding digital communication devices.

Talk Page

Other Wikipedians have noted the lack of adequate definitions of “Digital Society” and “Digital Literacy.” Like the contributors in the Talk Page who have added links that users can use to understand the topic better, I would add some knowledge on why the prevalence of the digital divide in the U.S. is high.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_divide_in_the_United_States

Article 4 Title: Domestic Robot

Article Evaluation

Relevance

This article’s content is relevant as it discusses using robots in the household. The article looks into how robots have slowly been integrated into the household.

Neutrality

This article seems not to be written neutrally since it does not critique the use of domestic robots. The article focuses on using different types of indoor and outdoor robots.

Citations

This article is supported by numerous citations that provide insight into the topic. These citations are reliable as they include experts in robotics and publications from reliable sources.

Wikipedia’s Equity Gap

This article tackles one of Wikipedia’s equity gaps, which involves covering historically underrepresented subjects. The use of robots at home is historically underrepresented since robots were not used at home in the past.

Talk Page

Contributors in the Talk Page flaw the article for not providing an exhaustive classification of domestic robots. Other contributors propose that the article incorporates more details about the history of domestic robots. Therefore, I would add some knowledge about the possible harm of domestic robots.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_robot

Article 5 Title: 3D Printing

Article Evaluation

Relevance

This article’s content is relevant to the topic as it discusses the concept of 3D printing. The article looks into the historical development of this technology and its contemporary application.

Neutrality

This article is written neutrally, as it does not advocate or discourage the use of 3D printing. Instead, the article provides in-depth information on various elements of this tech.

Citations

The article is supported by over 200 citations that provide helpful information on the topic. These citations are reliable as they can be accessed quickly and are written by technology professionals and other intellectuals in related fields.

Wikipedia’s Equity Gap

Technology is a highly misrepresented subject; hence, by addressing 3D printing, its applications, and its impact, the article does a great job of tackling one of Wikipedia’s equity gaps.

Talk Page

Other Wikipedians on the Talk Page criticize this article for only providing surface-level information. Other contributors claim that the article is too long and that some sections should be shortened. I would contribute to this talk page by sharing similar sentiments. Addressing a topic like 3D printing requires in-depth knowledge to inform and transform readers.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3D_printing