User:Rjconti719/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Argula von Grumbach

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
Argula von Grumbach, whom we have studied in class, I found to be a particularly fascinating figure. Her article seems to be somewhat comprehensive and of medium length.

Evaluate the article
The lead section of the article gave an excellent overview and offered the most crucial information about Argula von Grumbach. Although it could use a few grammatical changes (and perhaps 1 or 2 organizational ones as well), the content of the article was reasonably extensive and easy to follow. The article maintained a neutral tone throughout and apparently gave appropriate weight to different categories and sides. Only one image accompanied the article (some sort of coin/carving?) that was captioned merely with the name "Argula von Grumbach." Additionally, the first in the list of External Links did not appear to work correctly. The references section was extremely limited (only 3 sources listed). According to the (extremely sparse) Talk section, this article falls under the categories of WikiProject Biography, WikiProject Lutheranism, WikiProject Germany, and WikiProject Women Writers.