User:Romarcum/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Atlanta Botanical Garden

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I choose the Atlanta Botanical Garden after seeing it under the Urban Forest in the United States category. Urban conservation is an area of interest to me, and learning about a city's effort to establish more green spaces is interesting to me. I specifically choose the Atlanta Botanical Garden because it's the only one listed that I can realistically visit at this time.

Evaluate the article
The introduction has a concise and clear introduction sentence. The introduction gives a good idea of the sections that follow, and a menu with headings is present on the left-hand side. While the information that is included in the article is not updated, The last mention of any exhibits added was when 19 exhibits were added in 2016. The article also doesn't mention the garden's national accreditation either. Overall, the article is written in a neutral tone with no persuasive language. The article is severely lacking in references for the information presentation. Only six citations are used for the entire article, and only one of the citation links works. There are no major grammar or spelling errors, but a few minor corrections are needed. The organization of the article could be reviewed and edited to incorporate more of the information available on the Atlanta Botanical Garden website. One image appears to possibly violate a license, and the image of the map indicating the location of Atlanta does not close properly once enlarged. The talk page does not show any current activity, with the last comment made in September of 2008, and the article highlights how much information the article is lacking. The talk page does show that the article is part of WikiProject Georgia and supported by the Atlanta task force. The article has been identified as a start class article. While the introduction gives the reader an idea about the Atlanta Botanical Garden, the rest of the article is severely lacking in information and citations. A reader can get more information from the Atlanta Botanical Garden website.