User:Romashkaya/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title
 * World Water Day


 * Article Evaluation
 * Content: Content is relevant to the topic and contains multiple links to bigger articles.
 * Tone: The tone is neutral
 * Sources and References: Multiple missing citations for the events, claims and terms. However, some link were not reliable.
 * Organization and writing quality: Writing quality could be improved, as well as the over-all topic organization the page.
 * Media: More media could be added to support yearly events and community achievements.
 * Page discussion: Not active, Archived by ClueBot III
 * Overall: 4/5


 * Sources
 * Follow up on the latest developments and events
 * UNESCO report, 2021
 * Water Day Celebration, 2021

Option 2

 * Article title
 * Water intoxication


 * Article Evaluation
 * Content: Opinionated, major claims are not supported by facts or scientific research.
 * Tone: Somewhat neutral
 * Sources and References: Multiple missing term links, claims are not supported by sources.
 * Organization and writing quality: The writing quality is above average. The article is organized but hard to follow.
 * Media: Highly underrepresented.
 * Page discussion: Exists, but many comments date as of late 2000's.
 * Overall: 2/5


 * Sources
 * Clinical Pathology Report
 * Toxicology Education Foundation

Option 3

 * Article title
 * Brackish water


 * Article Evaluation
 * Content: Organized, follows the topic.
 * Tone: Neutral, scientific.
 * Sources and References: Most terms are cited with relevant links. However, some claims miss supportive links.
 * Organization and writing quality: Writing quality is great, but can be edited to improve clarity.
 * Media: Underrepresented, one photo reference is present.
 * Page discussion: Exists, last edits made in 2018.
 * Overall: 3/5


 * Sources
 * Rives & Ocean

Option 4

 * Article title
 * Fresh water


 * Article Evaluation
 * Content: Rich, educational content that follows the topic and expands on the term development.
 * Tone: Scientific, neutral.
 * Sources and References: Supportive terms are cited, some concepts and claims miss citations.
 * Organization and writing quality: Great organization and writing quality, every topic is well covered and sub-categorized.
 * Media: Great media, many educational diagrams added.
 * Page discussion: Active and present, last update made on march 30, 2021.
 * Overall: 4/5


 * Sources
 * WWF Fresh Water sources
 * Fresh Water Cycle
 * The fresh Water Biome

Option 5

 * Article title
 * Water cycle


 * Article Evaluation
 * Content: Correspond to the theme, educational.
 * Tone: Neutral.
 * Sources and References: Missing terms and concept citations. Overall, citations in the text are valid.
 * Organization and writing quality: Good organization! However, the sub-topics could be distributed in a better (easy to follow) way.
 * Media: Highly present, helps to support the claims and expand the knowledge base.
 * Page discussion: Exists, but not as active in present. Last edit noted in 2018.
 * Overall: 4/5


 * Sources
 * NASA's scholarly overview
 * NOAA education base