User:SammyGatenby/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Ad Astra (film)

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because it is a science fiction film, which did quite well in its cinema release, especially in its critical reception, yet failed at the box office. In this way, its C-Class rating should be easily identified and changed

Evaluate the article
Lead Section: It does have a good introductory sentence, including only information hat is also present in the rest of the article. I would say that there is detail and concise, really synthesising the information form the rest of the article into the first paragraph. It does explicitly have a brief description of the article's major sections but alludes to them

Content: All the content is up to date and relevant. It seems that the 'Release' section is the most neglected, with a noticeable lack of content compared to the other sections. Overall it does seem to cover all bases, though each could be more detailed e.g more details from the actual filming of the Ad Astra

Tone and Balance: The article seems to only state facts of the film, where it was done, quotations that were recorded. There is no biased position, though there could be something stated around the Rotten Tomatoes critical responses chosen as to present the film in a certain way.

Sources and References: Much of the sources and references come from News Outlets in the critical and box office response from the film. Most of from 2019, when the film was released, though not much from this last year. All links seem to work

Organization and Writing Quality: Concise, clear and well-written

Images and Media: There are only two images including a theatrical release poster and a photo of Brad Pitt visiting a space station. They adhere to copyright regulations, but do not add much to the article.

Talk Page discussion: The article is rated C-Class. Much of the discussion revolves around the release date, especially internationally.

Overall impressions: The article gives a basic understanding of the film, how it was produced and received, without giving much detail (perhaps relating to its lack of importance). It can be improved by going into greater detail on the production of the film and more emphasis on its reception, highlighting this difference within the critical opinion and public opinion.