User:ScienceBuzz/sandbox

silica cycle

The content of the article is factually accurate yet sometimes utilizes obscure examples, when simple ones may have been better. For example, the chemical formula for wollastonite was provided, even though quartz is the more recognizable silicate. Additionally, it may be possible that using a common example, such as quartz, may make this more approachable to the general public.

While factually accurate, the tone of the article glosses over complicated concepts, instead of simplifying the language where necessary.

There are 7 total sources, all come from peer-reviewed literature, and initial review indicates that the sources are scientifically sound. Three of the sources are quality, general use articles which provide additional information about the silica cycle. The other sources may be more specific than the citing language strictly requires. For example, the opening statement: "Silicon is considered a bioessential element and is one of the most abundant elements on Earth." is supported by an article entitled A Novel Mechanism by which Silica Defends Grasses Against Herbivory. It may be possible that a more accessible article may provide more useful resources.

The talk page only contains generic Wiki information, indicating that this is a Wiki Education page and a WikiProject page which involves Chemistry and the Environment. Additionally, it has been graded as a C-class in terms of quality, and has been awarded a mid-importance classification. The talk page does not currently include discussion from the contributors.

Bibliography to add:
Bibliography