User:Serena Chen 009/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Weiyang District, Xi'an

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
This article is about one of the largest districts in the city of Xi'an -- one of the most important city of northwest China and the capital of Shaanxi province. For such an important geographical district, this article seems provides only a rough interaction of it.

Evaluate the article
The lead section does a good job on providing brief introduction to the article's topic. However, the information provided in the lead section consists most of the information in this article.

The content is relevant, yet out-dated and significantly lacking detailed information related to this topic.

The tone of this article is neutral. But giving the length of it, it is also hard for it to contain persuasive tones or biased viewpoints.

There are only 2 sources cited, both are relevant to the topic and up-to-date. But it seems like not all of the facts are welled backed by reliable sources.

The organization and written quality of this article is good. There are no grammatical errors in the few sentences provided, and all the information is written in a way that is easy to read.

The only one image included in this article does not provide enough visual information of the topic.

There is only one conversation in the Talk page: a question left unanswered by anyone.

Overall impression: this article talks about a useful topic, yet it is extremely short and incomplete. Detailed information from more credible sources is needed to expand and improve this article.