User:Shelbyyyw/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
WikiProject Water

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
This article is a basic article about water. I figured for practice just getting started, searching water on a WikiProject was a good start. Keeping the content relatable to class somewhat.

Evaluate the article
Honestly the article seems confusing. Maybe because it is a project but I just followed the provided steps to pick and article. There is a lead section that gives many separate wiki account links that relate to this project and briefing what it is about. There is not bold key term.

The content is relevant to the subject and I am not sure how up to date it is, but it is semi-active currently. I think the article is mostly a collaboration of other water articles and categories that are links from this original page.

The tone definitely seems the same throughout. Non biased and neutral.

I didn't personally see any sources on this page because it is a page of collaborations. But the linked pages have citations and sources when clicked on those pages which seem creditable, the few I looked at.

The page does have two relative images. One being water dripping from a faucet which is kinda funny but relatable. The other is a diagram of the related articles in importance. This is titled and seems decently organized and understandable.

The talk page was the most interesting part! It definitely helps me understand that this page really is a collaboration of other pages. The authors of this project discuss how they are going to take part in the other sub sections and why. It was interesting reading proposals and changes and why they want to be apart of this.

Honestly this was probably not the greatest article to evaluate, but, that being said it still showed me different ideas about how to understand how Wiki works. I hadn't known about WikiProjects and this seems like an interesting idea.