User:Sheng.n.yu/Choose an Article

Article Selection
Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

 * Article title: Zhao Jincai
 * Article Evaluation
 * This is an article on English Wikipedia which introduces Zhao Jincai. Everything in this article was relevant to the topic, but some information could be added to make this topic more complete. The tone used on this page was neutral, I do not find it has a bias or preference. Unfortunately, one of the links doe not work, so I do not know what the original sources are. It has a blank talk page, no comments left.
 * This is an article on English Wikipedia which introduces Zhao Jincai. Everything in this article was relevant to the topic, but some information could be added to make this topic more complete. The tone used on this page was neutral, I do not find it has a bias or preference. Unfortunately, one of the links doe not work, so I do not know what the original sources are. It has a blank talk page, no comments left.


 * Sources
 * Zhao Jincai
 * http://www.ic.cas.cn/jggk/zjys/201202/t20120214_3439671.html

Option 2

 * Article title:Xu Xiaobai
 * Article Evaluation:
 * This is an article on the Chinese Wikipedia, it introduces Xu Xiaobai, a female Chinese environmental chemist. I want to create an English Wikipedia page to introduce her, so I first look at her Chinese Wikipedia page, and if it is possible, to try to connect these two pages in a later exercise. All the content on the page was relevant to her,  with a neutral tone. There is nothing to distract me, and I do not find any bias or preferences. To improve the page, I could add a photo for her, from a reliable source, of course. Also, I can do some arrangements, to make the page more organized, based on her biography, research, and achievement.
 * This is an article on the Chinese Wikipedia, it introduces Xu Xiaobai, a female Chinese environmental chemist. I want to create an English Wikipedia page to introduce her, so I first look at her Chinese Wikipedia page, and if it is possible, to try to connect these two pages in a later exercise. All the content on the page was relevant to her,  with a neutral tone. There is nothing to distract me, and I do not find any bias or preferences. To improve the page, I could add a photo for her, from a reliable source, of course. Also, I can do some arrangements, to make the page more organized, based on her biography, research, and achievement.


 * Sources
 * https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%BE%90%E6%99%93%E7%99%BD
 * https://yswk.las.ac.cn/qiantai/Shouye_zhanshi.action?id=1995B09
 * https://yswk.las.ac.cn/qiantai/Shouye_zhanshi.action?id=1995B09

Option 3

 * Article title: Zhang Lina
 * Article Evaluation
 * This is an article on English Wikipedia which introduces Zhang Lina. The content on the page was all relevant to herself and does not make me feel having any bias or preference, it is neutral. But, the content was a little too short, and lack of a photo. All the links can be opened successfully, and they referenced to news publications and her information on Wuhan university, the place where she currently works. The other link was referenced t o another Wikipedia page. In order to improve and fill the page, I can make arrangements to make the information better organized, according to her biography, and research achievements.
 * This is an article on English Wikipedia which introduces Zhang Lina. The content on the page was all relevant to herself and does not make me feel having any bias or preference, it is neutral. But, the content was a little too short, and lack of a photo. All the links can be opened successfully, and they referenced to news publications and her information on Wuhan university, the place where she currently works. The other link was referenced t o another Wikipedia page. In order to improve and fill the page, I can make arrangements to make the information better organized, according to her biography, and research achievements.


 * Sources: Zhang Lina