User:Shivamp1999/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Marvel Cinematic Universe: Phase Three

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
The reason I chose this article is because I am a avid fan of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. I have been following this universe and the expansion of the series since the first phase. This article is important in a cultural aspect of today's generation. The precise planning and intertwining of characters has kept fans on their edge of the seat since Phase 1. My preliminary impression of the article is that it is well written and detailed enough where a person who is not knowledgeable on this topic can learn.

Evaluate the article
After reading this article, I believe that is written well and perfectly summarizes each section.

Lead Section:

The beginning section gives enough information for a non-fan to understand how Phase 4 works. The lead section accurately details the current movies and TV shows that are being released in phase 4. The lead does not include any unnecessary information. The lead is concise with the information that is present. It is split into readable sections that details about the start of, the movies, and TV shows in Phase 4.

Content:

The content of the article is relevant to the topic at hand. The information does not skew in any direction other than informative. The content is up-to-date did notice that one of sections needs to updated. Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantuamania was originally set to release in 2022, but there have been delays which ultimately pushed it back to 2023. It still states in earlier sections that it supposed to be released in 2022. The article does not deal with one of Wikipedia's equity gap.

Tone and Balance:

The article is written in a neutral tone. There are no signs of favoritism when reading the article. There are no claims that appear heavily biased toward a particular position. There are no sections that are over represented or underrepresented. Each section is detailed enough to get a grasp of what it is trying to explain. It is not exclusively stated, but Marvel tries to include minorities. The article does not try to persuade the reader towards a certain position. It displays information from a neutral point of view.

Sources and References

Yes, it seems that the facts in the articles have reliable source of information. If the source does not seem reliable, users put footnotes to add a better reference than the one used. Yes, all sources seem thorough. Each source is referencing a point in time when that fact was stated or introduced. Yes, the article is up-to-date. The most recent update that we have received about Phase 4 is the upcoming movie, She-Hulk. This was premiered on May 17, 2022. I do not think that their are better sources for this type of information other than news coverage or anything stated by any Disney employees about Marvel. The links do lead to sources and are not dead links (at least the handful I tried).

Organization and Writing Quality

The article is well written and spaces out each paragraph so the information does not get overwhelming. Each paragraph has enough information to get a grasp at the surface level knowledge of the topic. I did not notice any grammatical errors when reading the article. The article is broken off into three sections, the development phase, the movies, and the TV shows. Yes, the article includes images of directors and producers of the films and tv shows of Phase 4 of the MCU. Yes, the caption usually pertains the name, their role, and what movie/TV show they worked/working on. The images are laid out in a zig-zag pattern to not overwhelm the reader or have a repetitive nature.

Talk Page Discussion

The current conversations going around are about upcoming movies/TV shows and if they fit into the phase 4 category. There is a new TV show coming out called Echo and fans do not know if it is considered Phase 4. The article is rated C-Class or of low-importance. A C-Class rating is more or so for the casual reader. This helps someone get informed, but the article is not fully complete since changes are happening. Phase 1-3 is given a B-Class rating since the phase has been finished and cannot be edited anymore. This article is under the scope of the WikiProject Comics. This is a Wikipedia guide to Comics built by numerous people.

Overall Impressions

Overall, I believe the article to be well put together with the necessary information provided by other sources. Phase 4 is still not complete. In my opinion, this is a strong article. I believe this because it has numerous amount sources  from creators and such about Phase 4. I think the article could be improved by splitting the development section. I feel as if the paragraph is clumped together. I would think that the article is underdeveloped due to the fact that Phase 4 is still under production. From when Phase 4 was introduced, there were only a handful of movies and tv shows that were being released. Since then, numerous amount tv shows have been released that were unknown to fans.