User:Shylarose399/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Metacomet Ridge

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
It seems interesting with the large birds.

Evaluate the article
Metacomet Ridge is a valley with mountains and ridges in New England. It has many historical landmarks as wells as a diverse ecosystem. It has many traces of dinosaurs as well. It is one of many major raptor migration sights.

This article has a well written introduction to the topic. The article describes a explanation and over view of the topic. The article as a whole seems to be on topic and doesn't seem to saw away. The content within the article is roughly a year without any edits which is fairly up to date. As the Historical aspects of the article goes it seems to be overall neutral, perhaps it could be more detailed. For example, the article only discusses Nomenclature in a small brief paragraph that doesn't describe much. It does however, keep a good neutral tone throughout. The sources for this article are fairly old some dating as early as 2015. However, there is a large group of authors. The origination of the article could be better as some things to be out of order, for example make geology before geography or ecosystem before Nomenclature. Otherwise, I seen little to no grammar errors. This article seems to lack in pictures, I feel as if a beautiful landscape should have more imagery. The images are well captioned and simple. In the Talk page it seems to mostly be other schools projects. Overall i liked this article, it was a little lacking in some places. All the things I mentioned could all be improved.