User:Snowded/nlp case

Site with details on Comaze here

Brenda Lo

section blanking on page previously focus of AJRG by Lo

Another IP and ActionPotential http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk%3ANeuro-linguistic_programming&action=historysubmit&diff=365783803&oldid=365751026

IP 211.31.25.27 making changes to Action Potential user page  http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User%3AAction_potential&action=historysubmit&diff=40636495&oldid=39334328

Action Potential’s previous username was Comaze:

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Neuro-linguistic_programming&diff=prev&oldid=21032476

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Neuro-linguistic_programming&diff=prev&oldid=21350223

Confirmation from Brenda Lo that IP is Scott and that she has been canvassed

Further canvassing - a dedicated web site no less here by @OzNLP and another although with only one follower one suspects this is juvenile

OzNLP Twitter campaign in 2011 here

Adding another editors name to a sock puppet list without proper investigation

Arbcom ruling re Comaze

NLP discussion forum - AndyB

where AndyB endorses sock accusation

Personal attacks by Action Potential as an IP and by the meat puppet

Continued personal attacks without evidence by the meat puppet

links to commercial promotion activities:

. Following the lead it shows some familiar editing style (misleading edit summaries):   

The author and webmaster of NLP.com.au is S.C of Comaze.com 

The companies and  are virtually the same company. Most of the trainers are from

The focus of those sites is New Code NLP, advertising sessions with John Grinder. Action Potential/Comaze earlier edits relating to Inspiritive:

Inspiritive related edit as IP

Commercial related link (Collingwoods ) as Action Potential/Comaze  Link to commercial inspiritive site as Action Potential/Comaze  On Representational Systems article as Action Potential/Comaze 

Adding Inspiritive as IP122 

Tagging tendency   

July
Another new IP emerges withsimilar edits Followed by a new SPA taking the same tagging strategy first set of edits here

December
One time edit threatening legal action etc here

And another SPA making the same tired accusations here

More promotional stuff from an SPA Here

Reference to Scott and Inspirative by James Donaly here

Another IP that looks to be ActionPotential here  and editing on the same subject on the talk page here

another SPA emerges

And an |another IP making very similar edits to 122.108.140.210 TUrns out it is just the same editor using an iPad  -- Snowded  TALK  10:55, 27 December 2011 (UTC)

Edit by Encylotadd referencing the off wiki stuff in detail

January
First SPA of the year with a one time edit

Latest SPA, first ever edit here

CoI accusations and Sock Puppetry raised again here by Encloytadd. -- Snowded TALK  08:32, 12 January 2012 (UTC)
 * actual dif

The serial editors

 * 1) User:Comaze, subject to Arbcom injunction account redirected to Action Potential
 * 2) User:Action potential (user page linked to Scott Coleman of comaze.com) edits from  23rd August 2005 to 24th July 2010 (and we have six months of peace thereafter)
 * 3) User:122.108.140.210 comes in after a period of silence, but is linked to other SPAs via web sites for New Code NLP. Here we have  confirmation from Brenda Lo that IP is Scott and that she has been canvassed before she was blocked.  Contributes from   12th January 2011 to 29th January 2012
 * 4) User:122.x.x.x link shown by this edit shows the IP is 122.108.140.210  edits from 26th January 2012

All are SPA accounts are promote New Code NLP, IP addresses all from Sydney area

Enemesis. And right on schedule another one arrives in February 2012. Admits to previously editing as Juzzyfelt here although no such user exists. Normal rant and then the standard Healey accusation here

[ANI material that needs refactoring into a formal case against 122.x.x.x

Admin dealing with sock puppetry charge here

Juzzyfett was the name not Juzzyfelt. there were others that came to mind when I tried to remember back to that time. I should also say I am not sure of how to find a user. If you would show me I can try these out as well. Enemesis (talk) 06:06, 22 November 2012 (UTC)

Nov/Dec 2012
Another new IP from Sydney |emerges with the normal protests, then creates a new user ID User:Reconsolidation confirmed here
 * And another newbe SPA User:CaitrionaReed

Enemesis material plus admission by Enemesis that s/he is an NLP practitioner

And another User:Savannahcharles

and another User:An adaptive system is User:99.249.47.79 from Ontario Canada as evidenced [here]

And another User:Affableparts

And another User:Thomdez

And another User:121.75.90.169 but from Palmerstone North - I think that is a sock, check history

And an abusive IP here

And another User:Keithcampbell

And another User:LTMem who obviously comes from the meat farm as we get this HD reference

Not a newbe but a very occasional editor taking the line User:Jimjamjom and in the same category User:Sleeping Turtle

And another User:Redmarti

And another User:Umesh Soman more wise in the ways of Wikipedia

And another User:NBOliver

Earlier not directly on the page User:Eturk001

And another User:123.21.146.241

Classic edit warring by Comaze, on Christmas Day after a long period here and deleting comments on his talk page

And another User:Granville60

Early in November User talk:Mike00764 with possible link to inlp

Jan 2013
User:MastCell indefs with this comment

User:Bobbollard another SPI making an identical edit request Snowded  TALK 05:44, 12 January 2013 (UTC)

User:Raczy activates after a few token edits in 2008

User:Saquigley again making almost the same opening line so it must be a meat farm output

Post blocking of Reconsolidation
LTMem who started editing on the 14th December makes accusations on another brand new user User talk:Nlpskills talk page linking one of the meat puppet sites which contains various accusations (including some bazaar assertions) and also advice on how to manage wikipedia editing. The same accusation, linked with a "back off the NLP article" statement were made here. A previous used. The linked "socks" site has been referenced by several SPAs. Back in January 2012 Encyclotadd raised both the sock accusation and a COI one with admin Atama who conducted a detailed investigation. In the interests of full disclosure Encylotadd contacted me off wiki shortly after this and we have met and talked several times since.

21st Jan 2013 sees a series of negative contributions including another repetition of the HeadleyDown accusation. Also tagging PoV without giving any supporting evidence on the talk page

Then taking a break when a report is likely - similar pattern to Comaze

I suspect LTMem is a sock puppet of Andy (not sure of that yet, but its his style)

Other sites/useful or interesting stuff
On [Brandler

Feb 2013
Another new SPA editor User_talk:Mrdanielsmith

Personal attack from Enemesis http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk%3ANeuro-linguistic_programming&diff=541152499&oldid=541119955

April/May 2013
User:Jdemars1 inactive since 2010 and only minor before then makes the usual changes with the "bias" accusation User:WykiP starts January 2013 with a lot of work on manual of style, claim of new editor starts on article in May reverting a revert per [WP:BRD]] with a "Prefer Jdemars1"

User:Raczy requests deletion of his page. Page states he is an NLP practitioner but edits anonymously diff here. Screen shot taken