User:Stevenli12/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Robert Sibley Volcanic Regional Preserve

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
This article is closely related to our class' research into the ecology surrounding Berkeley. It gives a detailed breakdown of a regional park and the biology within the area.

Evaluate the article
The lead is solid however it does not include information that breaks down what sections the article includes. The content addresses a good variety of information regarding the park it may however fail to include information regarding the geologic and biological features of the park. The tone is very neutral with little to no opinions being given as it largely just presents objective facts. Source wise i made sure to check that all the links were still up to date as well as active. For images and media the article contains relevant photos organized in the appropriate sections that are laid out with appropriate captions and do abide by the wikipedia copyright regulation. When it comes to the talk page discussion the page first notes the article is of mid level importance on Wikiprojects. The conversations themselves focus on the exact geographic designation of the park and ensuring that the terminology is factual which is something that we usually ignore during class. Overall the article is decently strong with a well organized and content rich page. It could be improved with a larger focus on the bio diversity of the area and therefore is not fully complete as it has room to grow.