User:Studentck1/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Harry Potter

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article due to my interest in the subject. I want to use this module as a tool and the way I feel I will best learn is through an article that I can not only understand but enjoy. My preliminary impression of the article is that it is entertaining.

Evaluate the article
Lead section:

The lead section gives a brief summary of the subject, it does not introduce the sections of the article, it is very concise and lacks detail.

Content:

The content of this article is fully detailed and not lacking any aspects.

Tone/balance:

The tone of this article is very neutral. It is very informative with no bias or obvious under/over represented view points.

Sources/references:

All sources are properly referenced as well as quoted throughout the article. The source links do indeed work after being checked.

Organization/writing quality:

The article is well written. it is concise, clear, as well as void of grammatical or spelling errors.

Talk page discussion:

After viewing the talk page section of this article it Is very clear that this article is constantly contributed to, most likely due to the popularity of the subject.

Overall impressions:

My overall evaluation of this article is that it is a well written, well edited article on a very popular subject which may have made creating an article on the topic even more subject to criticism yet it succeeds in its purpose of informing its readers on the subject of Harry Potter as a whole without going into too much detail which can be distracting. overall it is a good article.