User:Svn38/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Responsible disclosure

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I was looking for an article that discussed policy requiring the reporting of a ransom attack on county and local governments. Understanding disclosure on ransom attacks and details of what must be reported is pertinent to my research. I found two articles, (i) Responsible disclosure and (ii) Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act, and chose the former for this assignment.

Evaluate the article
The Lead section has a notice that more citations are required for verification.

The Lead section could be shorter and concise on the topic definition(s), moving some of the topics within it to the content section to develop further in the page.

The Content section outline is not comprehensive, nor fleshed out sufficiently for sections it has listed.

The article makes claims without references to bring validity from opinion, but from other sources.

There are some references, but the article does not develop the subject well.

The Talk pages provide very good suggestions, and feedback on what needs to be improved, as well as the importance of this topic.

Overall impression is that the article is could be valuable but it is incomplete.