User:Teklae/Evaluate an Article

Which article are you evaluating?
Saint Lucy

Why you have chosen this article to evaluate?
I chose this article because I worked on it for my Purgatorio assessment. It is important in various cultural, religious, and literary levels. St. Lucia is a part of Christianity, and she is also a character in the Divine Comedy. She is also very important in Sweden because of St. Lucia's Day. My initial impression of this article is that it seems pretty detailed.

Evaluate the article
The lead is concise and relevant; I would maybe just briefly mention St. Lucy's major importance in Scandinavia and touch on her presence in literature. The content and tone both seem good and appropriate. I noticed that in the section about popular celebration, there are no sources for the information on the Italian, Hungarian, and Filipino celebrations, so that should be fixed. The organization seems standard and is straight-forward. I think the images are good, but it could be a good idea to add images of churches or places named after St. Lucy. This article is part of Wikidante, I believe, but most of the conversations happening in the talk page are about St. Lucia's Day. I found the argument about whether the article should refer to the holiday as St. Lucy's Day or St. Lucia's Day most interesting. Overall, this article is thorough and explores St. Lucy's importance from multiple angles, both religious, cultural, and literary. The article is pretty developed. My main criticism is that some of the citations are lacking.